Western Australian Bills

[Index] [Search] [Download] [Related Items] [Help]


This is a Bill, not an Act. For current law, see the Acts databases.


ANIMAL WELFARE BILL 1999

                       Western Australia



            Animal Welfare Bill 1999


                          CONTENTS



                  Part 1 -- Preliminary
1.    Short title                                                2
2.    Commencement                                               2
3.    Content and intent                                         2
4.    Act binds the Crown                                        2
5.    Interpretation                                             3
        Part 2 -- Use of animals for scientific
                      purposes
6.    Unlicensed use of animals for scientific purposes
      prohibited                                                 6
7.    Carrying on business supplying animals for scientific
      purposes                                                   6
8.    Application for issue or renewal of licence                7
9.    Matters to be considered                                   7
10.   Minister to issue or renew or decline to issue or renew    8
11.   Conditions on licences                                     8
12.   Further conditions may be imposed                          9
13.   Licensee to ensure staff and students comply with
      conditions                                                10
14.   Display of licence and code of practice                   10
15.   Duration of a licence                                     11
16.   Licence not transferable                                  11


                                                                page i


                             79--1
Animal Welfare Bill 1999



Contents


   17.     Suspension and revocation                               11
   18.     Register of licences                                    13
               Part 3 -- Offences against animals
   19.     Cruelty to animals                                      15
   20.     Defence -- self-defence or protecting another person
           or an animal                                            16
   21.     Defence -- veterinary care                              17
   22.     Defence -- authorized by law                            17
   23.     Defence -- normal animal husbandry                      18
   24.     Defence -- killing pests                                18
   25.     Defence -- code of practice                             19
   26.     Defence -- stock fending for itself                     19
   27.     Defence -- releasing animals into the wild              19
   28.     Defence -- where person in charge is not in actual
           custody                                                 20
   29.     Defence -- prescribed use of devices                    20
   30.     Defence -- prescribed surgical or similar operations,
           practices and activities                                21
   31.     Possession of things intended to inflict cruelty        21
   32.     Shooting, hunting or fighting captive animals           21
                           Part 4 -- Inspectors
               Division 1 -- Appointment of inspectors
   33.     Appointment of general inspectors                       23
   34.     Appointment of scientific inspectors                    24
   35.     Restricted appointments                                 24
   36.     Identification card                                     26
           Division 2 -- Functions and powers of inspectors
   37.     Functions and powers of inspectors                      26
   38.     Power to enter a place                                  27
   39.     Power to enter vehicles                                 28
   40.     Care of animals                                         29
   41.     Humane destruction of animals                           29
   42.     Seizure of animals                                      30
   43.     Seizure of other property                               30
   44.     Dealing with seized property                            31

page ii
                                                Animal Welfare Bill 1999



                                                               Contents


45.   Dealing with seized fauna                                    33
46.   Power to require information                                 33
47.   Other powers of inspectors                                   33
48.   Performance of an inspector's functions                      35
       Division 3 -- Additional powers of scientific
                       inspectors
49.   Direction to suspend use and referral to animal ethics
      committee                                                    36
50.   Directions to licensees and their staff                      36
51.   Power to require information                                 38
52.   Advice regarding licensing matters                           38
53.   Attendance at meetings of animal ethics committees           39
                  Part 5 -- Enforcement
           Division 1 -- Additional court orders
54.   Court may order a post mortem                                40
55.   Orders additional to penalty                                 40
56.   Order for reimbursement of costs                             42
57.   Order for retention of seized property                       43
58.   Costs                                                        44
                    Division 2 -- Warrants
59.   Grounds for a search warrant                                 44
60.   Grounds for a warrant to seize animal                        44
61.   Form of warrant                                              44
62.   Urgent warrants                                              45
             Division 3 -- Infringement notices
63.   Definition for Division 3                                    46
64.   Appointment of authorized persons                            46
65.   Giving infringement notices                                  46
66.   Content of infringement notice                               47
67.   Extension of time to pay                                     47
68.   Withdrawal of infringement notice                            47
69.   Benefit of paying modified penalty                           48
70.   Application of modified penalties paid                       48




                                                                  page iii
Animal Welfare Bill 1999



Contents



              Division 4 -- Review of decisions and appeals
   71.       Interpretation for Division 4                            48
   72.       Aggrieved person may make an objection                   49
   73.       Dealing with an objection                                50
   74.       Aggrieved person may appeal                              50
   75.       Dealing with an appeal                                   51
                           Division 5 -- Offences
   76.       Misleading information                                   52
   77.       Obstruction of inspectors                                52
   78.       Pretending to be an inspector                            53
   79.       Continuing offences                                      53
   80.       Liability of officers for offence by body corporate or
             scientific establishments                                53
   81.       Partnerships                                             55
                            Division 6 -- General
   82.       Commencement of proceedings for offences                 55
   83.       Evidentiary provisions                                   56
   84.       Breach of code of practice not sufficient to prove
             cruelty                                                  57
   85.       Death of animal not sufficient to prove cruelty          57
   86.       Application of fines                                     58
   87.       Disposal of forfeited property                           58
   88.       Penalties for body corporate                             58
                        Part 6 -- Miscellaneous
   89.       General power of Executive Director                      60
   90.       Delegation                                               60
   91.       Improper use of information                              60
   92.       Protection from liability                                61
   93.       Owner may claim compensation for injury or death         61
   94.       Regulations                                              63
           Part 7 -- Repeal, consequential amendments
                    and transitional provisions
   95.       Act repealed                                             64
   96.       Fish Resources Management Act 1994 amended               64


page iv
                                           Animal Welfare Bill 1999



                                                          Contents


97.   Wildlife Conservation Act 1950 amended                  65
98.   Transitional                                            66
                     Defined Terms




                                                             page v
                           Western Australia



                     LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY



                 Animal Welfare Bill 1999


                               A Bill for


An Act to provide for the welfare, safety and health of animals, to
regulate the use of animals for scientific purposes, and for related
purposes.



The Parliament of Western Australia enacts as follows:




                                                                 page 1
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 1       Preliminary

     s. 1



                              Part 1 -- Preliminary
     1.         Short title
                This Act may be cited as the Animal Welfare Act 1999.

     2.         Commencement
 5        (1)   This Act comes into operation on a day fixed by proclamation.
          (2)   Different days may be fixed under subsection (1) for different
                provisions.

     3.         Content and intent
          (1)   This Act provides for the protection of animals by --
10               (a) regulating the people who may use animals for scientific
                       purposes, and the manner in which they may be used;
                       and
                 (b) prohibiting cruelty to, and other inhumane or improper
                       treatment of, animals.
15        (2)   This Act intends to --
                 (a) promote and protect the welfare, safety and health of
                       animals;
                 (b) ensure the proper and humane care and management of
                       all animals in accordance with generally accepted
20                     standards; and
                 (c) reflect the community's expectation that people who are
                       in charge of animals will ensure that they are properly
                       treated and cared for.

     4.         Act binds the Crown
25        (1)   This Act binds the Crown in right of the State and, so far as the
                legislative power of Parliament permits, in all its other
                capacities.

     page 2
                                                        Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                                        Preliminary       Part 1

                                                                             s. 5



          (2)   Despite subsection (1), the Crown in any capacity --
                 (a) is not required to hold a licence or obtain an approval
                       under this Act; and
                 (b) is not liable to be prosecuted for an offence.

 5   5.         Interpretation
                In this Act --
                "Agriculture WA" means the department of the Public Service
                     principally assisting with the administration of the
                     Agriculture Act 1988;
10              "animal" means --
                     (a) a live vertebrate; or
                     (b) a live invertebrate of a prescribed kind,
                     other than a human or a fish (as defined in the Fish
                     Resources Management Act 1994);
15              "animal ethics committee" means an animal ethics committee
                     established by a scientific establishment in accordance with
                     the scientific use code;
                "CALM" means the department of the Public Service
                     principally assisting with the administration of the
20                   Conservation and Land Management Act 1984;
                "code of practice" means a code of practice adopted under
                     section 94(2)(d);
                "Department" means the department of the Public Service
                     principally assisting the Minister in the administration of
25                   this Act;
                "Executive Director" means the chief executive officer of the
                     Department;
                "fauna" has the same meaning as in the Wildlife Conservation
                     Act 1950;


                                                                          page 3
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 1       Preliminary

     s. 5



              "Fisheries Western Australia" means the department of the
                   Public Service principally assisting with the administration
                   of the Fish Resources Management Act 1994;
              "general inspector" means a police officer or a person
 5                 appointed as a general inspector under section 33;
              "harm" includes --
                   (a) injury;
                   (b) pain; and
                   (c) distress evidenced by severe, abnormal physiological
10                       or behavioural reactions;
              "inspector" means a general inspector or a scientific inspector;
              "licence" means a licence issued under Part 2;
              "non-residential place" --
                   (a) means any place except a building, vehicle or other
15                       structure in which a person ordinarily lives; and
                   (b) includes gardens, yards or other land surrounding,
                         and sheds or other outbuildings near, such a building
                         or other structure;
              "person in charge", in relation to an animal, means --
20                 (a) the owner of the animal;
                   (b) a person who has actual physical custody or control
                         of the animal;
                   (c) if the person referred to in paragraph (b) is a member
                         of staff of another person, that other person; or
25                 (d) the owner or occupier of the place or vehicle where
                         the animal is or was at the relevant time;
              "place" means anywhere at all, whether or not that place can be
                   moved, but does not include a vehicle;
              "RSPCA" means The Royal Society for the Prevention of
30                 Cruelty to Animals, Western Australia (Incorporated);

     page 4
                                            Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                            Preliminary       Part 1

                                                                 s. 5



     "scientific establishment" means a person who uses, or whose
          staff or students use, animals for scientific purposes;
     "scientific inspector" means a person appointed as a scientific
          inspector under section 33(5) or 34;
 5   "scientific purposes" means acquiring, developing or
          demonstrating knowledge or techniques in a scientific
          discipline, other than in prescribed circumstances, and
          includes --
          (a) teaching;
10        (b) research;
          (c) product development or testing; and
          (d) carrying out a prescribed activity;
     "scientific use code" means the prescribed code of practice for
          the care and use of animals for scientific purposes;
15   "staff", in relation to a person, includes --
          (a) all the people working for, or engaged by, that person
                 whether as officers, employees, agents, contractors,
                 volunteers or in any other capacity;
          (b) if the person is a scientific establishment, all the
20               people who use the establishment's facilities for
                 scientific purposes;
          (c) if the person is a body corporate, its directors,
                 secretary and executive officers; and
          (d) if the person is a partnership, the partners;
25   "vehicle" includes a train, vessel, aircraft and any other thing
          used as a means of transport;
     "veterinary surgeon" means a veterinary surgeon registered
          under the Veterinary Surgeons Act 1960.




                                                              page 5
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 2       Use of animals for scientific purposes

     s. 6



            Part 2 -- Use of animals for scientific purposes
     6.         Unlicensed use of animals for scientific purposes prohibited
          (1)   A person must not use animals for scientific purposes unless --
                  (a) the person is --
 5                        (i) a scientific establishment that holds; or
                         (ii) a member of staff of, or a student at, a scientific
                               establishment that holds,
                       a licence authorizing that use;
                  (b) the animal ethics committee of the scientific establishment
10                     has given approval, in accordance with the scientific use
                       code, for that person to so use the animals; and
                  (c) the person uses the animals in accordance with that
                       licence and approval.
                Penalty: $20 000 and imprisonment for one year.
15        (2)   A licensed scientific establishment must not allow animals to be
                used for scientific purposes at a place to which that licence
                relates unless that use is permitted under subsection (1).
                Penalty: $20 000 and imprisonment for one year.

     7.         Carrying on business supplying animals for scientific
20              purposes
          (1)   Subject to subsection (2), a person must not carry on a business
                of supplying animals for use for scientific purposes except in
                accordance with a licence authorizing the person to do so.
                Penalty: $20 000 and imprisonment for one year.
25        (2)   Subsection (1) does not apply to a person carrying on a business
                of supplying fauna that the person is licensed or authorized
                under the Wildlife Conservation Act 1950 to take for the
                purposes of that business.


     page 6
                                                           Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                Use of animals for scientific purposes       Part 2

                                                                               s. 8



     8.         Application for issue or renewal of licence
          (1)   An application for the issue or renewal of a licence is to be
                made to the Minister in the prescribed form and manner and is
                to be accompanied by the prescribed fee and any prescribed
 5              information.
          (2)   An applicant must provide to the Minister any other information
                relating to the application that the Minister reasonably requires
                for the proper consideration of the application.
          (3)   An application for the renewal of a licence must be made no
10              later than 42 days before the day on which the licence is due to
                expire or at such later time as the Minister, having regard to
                section 10(2)(b), allows.
     9.         Matters to be considered
          (1)   The Minister must not issue or renew a licence to use animals
15              for scientific purposes unless the Minister is satisfied that --
                  (a) the scientific establishment either --
                           (i) has an animal ethics committee; or
                          (ii) has made arrangements for the animal ethics
                                committee for another scientific establishment to
20                              act as its animal ethics committee;
                        and
                  (b) the scientific establishment complies with, and will
                        continue to comply with, the scientific use code.
          (2)   When considering an application for the issue or renewal of a
25              licence the Minister is to have regard to --
                   (a) whether the applicant and the applicant's staff are
                        experienced and competent --
                          (i) in the case of a licence to use animals for
                               scientific purposes, in using animals for
30                             scientific purposes; and

                                                                             page 7
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 2       Use of animals for scientific purposes

     s. 10



                          (ii)   in all cases, in caring for and handling animals of
                                 the kind to be used or supplied;
                  (b)    whether the applicant has, or any of the applicant's staff
                         or students have, been convicted of an offence under this
 5                       Act in the previous 3 years;
                   (c)   whether a licence held by the applicant has ever been
                         suspended or revoked or the applicant has ever been
                         disqualified from holding a licence;
                  (d)    whether the welfare, safety and health of the animals is
10                       adequately protected;
                   (e)   any prescribed matters; and
                   (f)   whether, in all other respects, the Minister considers it
                         appropriate for the applicant to hold the licence.

     10.         Minister to issue or renew or decline to issue or renew
15         (1)   After considering an application in accordance with section 9
                 the Minister is to --
                   (a) issue or renew the licence in the prescribed form; or
                   (b) decline to issue or renew the licence.
           (2)   If the Minister declines to issue or renew a licence the Minister
20               is to give to the applicant written notice setting out the decision
                 and the reasons for it --
                    (a) in the case of an application for the issue of a licence, no
                          more than 28 days after the decision is made; and
                   (b) in the case of an application for a renewal, at least
25                        21 days before the current licence expires.

     11.         Conditions on licences
           (1)   Every licence is subject to the conditions prescribed in respect
                 of licences of a class to which the licence belongs.


     page 8
                                                             Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                  Use of animals for scientific purposes       Part 2

                                                                                s. 12



           (2)   Conditions prescribed for the purposes of subsection (1) may
                 deal with any matter relating to the welfare, safety and health of
                 the animals including --
                   (a) the place at which the animals may be used or kept;
 5                 (b) codes of practice (other than the scientific use code) that
                         must be complied with;
                   (c) the conditions under which the animals are, or are not, to
                         be kept;
                   (d) the facilities and equipment that are, or are not, to be
10                       used in relation to the animals;
                   (e) the procedures to be followed by the licensee and the
                         licensee's staff and students in specified situations; and
                    (f) the people who are, or are not, to be involved in the care
                         of the animals.
15         (3)   It is also a condition of each licence to use animals for scientific
                 purposes that animals must not be used for scientific purposes
                 unless they are used in accordance with the scientific use code.

     12.         Further conditions may be imposed
           (1)   When issuing or renewing a licence the Minister may impose
20               such other conditions as are set out in, or provided to the
                 licensee with, the licence.
           (2)   The Minister may amend or remove the conditions imposed on
                 a licence under this section by giving at least 21 days written
                 notice of the amendment to the licensee.
25         (3)   Conditions imposed under this section may deal with any matter
                 in respect of which conditions could be prescribed for the
                 purposes of section 11(1).




                                                                               page 9
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 2       Use of animals for scientific purposes

     s. 13



     13.         Licensee to ensure staff and students comply with conditions
                 A licensee must take all reasonable steps to ensure that the
                 licensee's staff and students comply with the conditions to
                 which the licence is subject.
 5               Penalty: $10 000 and imprisonment for 6 months.

     14.         Display of licence and code of practice
           (1)   Subject to subsection (2), a licensee must cause a copy of the
                 licence to be exhibited to the public at each place where --
                    (a) animals are used for scientific purposes; or
10                 (b) animals to be supplied for use for scientific purposes are
                         kept.
                 Penalty: $1 000.
           (2)   A licensee need not cause a copy of the licence to be exhibited
                 at places where field work is being carried out ("field site") but
15               if a copy of the license is not exhibited --
                    (a) the licensee must ensure that a person at the field site
                         has a copy of the licence with him or her at that site; and
                    (b) that person must make the copy of the licence available
                         to a member of the public on request.
20               Penalty: $1 000.
           (3)   If a licence is subject to a condition that a code of practice be
                 complied with the licensee must --
                   (a) cause a copy of the code to be exhibited to; or
                   (b) make copies of the code available to,
25               all the licensee's staff and students at each place, other than
                 field sites, where --
                   (c) animals are used for scientific purposes; or


     page 10
                                                             Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                  Use of animals for scientific purposes       Part 2

                                                                                s. 15



                  (d)   animals to be supplied for use for scientific purposes are
                        kept.
                 Penalty: $1 000.
           (4)   If a licence to use animals for scientific purposes is subject to a
 5               condition that a code of practice be complied with the licensee
                 must give a copy of the code to the relevant animal ethics
                 committee.
                 Penalty: $1 000.

     15.         Duration of a licence
10               A licence remains in force for 3 years or any shorter period
                 specified in it, unless before then it is suspended or revoked or
                 the licensee is disqualified from holding the licence.

     16.         Licence not transferable
                 A licence is not transferable.

15   17.         Suspension and revocation
           (1)   The Minister may, by giving written notice to the licensee,
                 suspend a licence for up to 3 months if the Minister is satisfied
                 that --
                   (a) the licensee has, or any of the licensee's staff or students
20                       have, committed an offence under this Act since the
                         licence was issued or last renewed;
                   (b) if the licence was due for renewal, the Minister would
                         not, having regard to the criteria set out in section 9,
                         renew it;
25                 (c) in the case of a licence to use animals for scientific
                         purposes the relevant animal ethics committee has failed
                         to comply with the scientific use code in relation to the
                         licensee's use of animals; or


                                                                             page 11
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 2       Use of animals for scientific purposes

     s. 17



                (d)   for any other reason the welfare, safety and health of an
                      animal would be under threat if the licence remained in
                      force.
        (2)    The Minister may, by giving written notice to the licensee,
 5             revoke a licence if --
                 (a) the Minister is satisfied that the licence was obtained by
                      fraud or misrepresentation; or
                 (b) the licence is suspended and the Minister is satisfied,
                      during the 14 days before the end of the suspension
10                    period, that the licensee has not taken reasonable steps
                      to ensure that the grounds for the suspension have been
                      remedied and will not recur.
        (3)    When revoking a licence the Minister may also disqualify the
               licensee from applying for another licence before the date on
15             which the revoked licence would have lapsed if it had not been
               revoked.
        (4)    Before exercising a power referred to in subsection (1) or (2) the
               Minister is to --
                (a) give the licensee written notice --
20                       (i) stating the intention to suspend or revoke the
                              licence;
                        (ii) setting out the grounds for the intended
                              suspension or revocation; and
                       (iii) advising that the licensee has 7 days (or any
25                            longer period the Minister considers appropriate)
                              within which to respond to the notice;
                      and
                (b) have due regard to any response to the notice made
                      within that time.



     page 12
                                                             Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                  Use of animals for scientific purposes       Part 2

                                                                                s. 18



           (5)   A licensee must deliver a suspended or revoked licence to the
                 Minister as soon as practicable, and in any event within 7 days,
                 after the suspension or revocation.
                 Penalty: $1 000.
 5         (6)   Subject to subsection (2)(b), a suspended licence delivered to the
                 Minister under subsection (5) is to be returned to the licensee as
                 soon as practicable after the end of the suspension period.

     18.         Register of licences
           (1)   The Executive Director is to keep a register of all licences
10               showing, for each licence --
                   (a) the name of the licensee;
                   (b) whether it is a licence --
                           (i) to use animals for scientific purposes; or
                          (ii) to carry on business supplying animals for use
15                              for scientific purposes,
                        and in the case of subparagraph (i), the scientific
                        purposes for which the animals are or may be used;
                   (c) details of the places where the animals are or may be
                        used or kept;
20                 (d) the dates of issue, renewal and expiry;
                   (e) any conditions to which the licence is subject (other than
                        those imposed by section 11);
                    (f) details of any suspension or revocation of the licence or
                        disqualification of the licensee; and
25                 (g) any prescribed details.
           (2)   A licensee must notify the Executive Director of any change in
                 the details referred to in subsection (1)(a), (c) or (g) within
                 14 days of the change occurring.
                 Penalty: $1 000.

                                                                             page 13
    Animal Welfare Bill 1999
    Part 2       Use of animals for scientific purposes

    s. 18



       (3)    A person may, at any time during office hours --
               (a) inspect the register free of charge; and
               (b) purchase a copy of, or an extract from, the register.
       (4)    The Executive Director is to ensure that copies of, or extracts
5             from, the register are available and that the price at which they
              are sold does not exceed the cost of providing them.




    page 14
                                                         Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                             Offences against animals      Part 3

                                                                              s. 19



                     Part 3 -- Offences against animals
     19.         Cruelty to animals
           (1)   A person must not be cruel to an animal.
                 Penalty: Minimum -- $1 000.
 5                        Maximum -- $20 000 and imprisonment for one year.
           (2)   Without limiting subsection (1) a person, whether or not the
                 person is a person in charge of the animal, is cruel to an animal
                 if the person --
                    (a) tortures, mutilates, maliciously beats or wounds, abuses,
10                        torments, or otherwise ill-treats, the animal;
                    (b) uses a prescribed inhumane device on the animal;
                    (c) intentionally or recklessly poisons the animal;
                   (d) does any prescribed act to, or in relation to, the animal;
                          or
15                  (e) in any other way causes the animal unnecessary harm.
           (3)   Without limiting subsection (1) a person in charge of an animal
                 is cruel to an animal if the animal --
                    (a) is transported in a way that causes, or is likely to cause,
                          it unnecessary harm;
20                 (b) is confined, restrained or caught in a manner that --
                             (i) is prescribed; or
                            (ii) causes, or is likely to cause, it unnecessary harm;
                    (c) is worked, driven, ridden or otherwise used --
                             (i) when it is not fit to be so used or has been over
25                               used; or
                            (ii) in a manner that causes, or is likely to cause, it
                                 unnecessary harm;


                                                                            page 15
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 3       Offences against animals

     s. 20



                  (d)    is not provided with proper and sufficient food or water;
                  (e)    is not provided with such shelter, shade or other
                         protection from the elements as is reasonably necessary
                         to ensure its welfare, safety and health;
 5                 (f)   is abandoned, whether at the place where it is normally
                         kept or elsewhere;
                  (g)    is subjected to a prescribed surgical or similar operation,
                         practice or activity;
                  (h)    suffers harm which could be alleviated by the taking of
10                       reasonable steps;
                   (i)   suffers harm as a result of a prescribed act being carried
                         out on, or in relation to, it; or
                   (j)   is, in any other way, caused unnecessary harm.
     20.         Defence -- self-defence or protecting another person or an
15               animal
           (1)   Subject to subsections (2) and (3), it is a defence to a charge
                 under section 19 for a person to prove that --
                   (a) the animal was attacking, or threatening to attack, the
                        person, another person or another animal;
20                 (b) the person was defending himself or herself, another
                        person or an animal against the attack or threatened
                        attack; and
                   (c) the person did not use more force than was reasonably
                        necessary.
25         (2)   Subsection (1) does not provide a defence to a person who, in
                 the course of, or for the purpose of, committing an unlawful act,
                 enters or attempts to enter a place or vehicle --
                   (a) of which the person who has actual physical custody or
                         control of the animal is the occupier or a guard; or
30                 (b) occupied by the animal.

     page 16
                                                         Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                             Offences against animals      Part 3

                                                                              s. 21



           (3)   Subsection (1) does not provide a defence to a person if --
                  (a) the person provoked the attack or threatened attack;
                  (b) the person permitted or encouraged another animal to
                        attack or threaten the animal the subject of the charge; or
 5                (c) the animal the subject of the charge was being used
                        by --
                           (i) a police officer;
                          (ii) a prison officer under the Prisons Act 1981; or
                         (iii) a member of --
10                                  (I) the armed forces of the Commonwealth;
                                   (II) the Australian Federal Police;
                                  (III) the Australian Quarantine and
                                         Inspection Service; or
                                 (IV) the Australian Customs Service,
15                      in the course of his or her duties and the use of the
                        animal was not unreasonable in the circumstances.
     21.         Defence -- veterinary care
                 It is a defence to a charge under section 19(1) (other than an
                 offence committed in circumstances described in section 19(3)(g))
20               for a person to prove that the person was a veterinary surgeon, or
                 was acting on the instructions of a veterinary surgeon, and was
                 providing the animal with veterinary care in accordance with
                 generally accepted veterinary practices.
     22.         Defence -- authorized by law
25               It is a defence to a charge under section 19(1) for a person to
                 prove that the person --
                    (a) was authorized by or under a written law to do the act
                          that is alleged to constitute the offence; and
                   (b) did the act in a humane manner.

                                                                            page 17
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 3       Offences against animals

     s. 23



     23.         Defence -- normal animal husbandry
                 It is a defence to a charge under section 19(1) for a person to
                 prove that the act alleged to constitute the offence was done --
                    (a) in accordance with a generally accepted animal
 5                        husbandry practice, other than a prescribed practice, that
                          is used in --
                             (i) farming or grazing activities;
                            (ii) the management of zoos, wildlife parks or
                                  similar establishments;
10                         (iii) the management of animal breeding
                                  establishments; or
                           (iv) the training of animals;
                          and
                   (b) in a humane manner.

15   24.         Defence -- killing pests
           (1)   It is a defence to a charge under section 19(1) for a person to
                 prove --
                    (a) that the act alleged to constitute the offence was done
                          while the person was attempting to kill pests;
20                 (b) that the person was attempting to kill pests in a manner
                          that is generally accepted as usual and reasonable for
                          killing pests of the kind the person was attempting to
                          kill; and
                    (c) if the animal the subject of the charge was not a pest,
25                        that the person took reasonable steps to ensure that
                          animals other than pests would not be harmed.
           (2)   In this section --
                 "pest" means a prescribed animal, fish or invertebrate.


     page 18
                                                        Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                            Offences against animals      Part 3

                                                                             s. 25



     25.         Defence -- code of practice
                 It is a defence to a charge under section 19(1) for a person to
                 prove that the person was acting in accordance with a relevant
                 code of practice.

 5   26.         Defence -- stock fending for itself
           (1)   It is a defence to a charge under section 19(1) committed in
                 circumstances described in section 19(3)(d), (e) or (f) for a
                 person to prove that --
                    (a) the animal is stock of a kind that is ordinarily left to
10                        roam at large on a pastoral property and to fend for
                          itself;
                   (b) the act alleged to constitute the offence does not involve
                          anything more than allowing the animal to so roam and
                          fend for itself; and
15                  (c) the property on which the animal was roaming was
                          reasonably capable of sustaining all the animals that
                          were roaming on it.
           (2)   In this section --
                 "stock" has the meaning it has in the Stock (Identification and
20                    Movement) Act 1970.

     27.         Defence -- releasing animals into the wild
                 It is a defence to a charge under section 19(1) committed in
                 circumstances described in section 19(3)(f) for a person to prove
                 that --
25                  (a) the animal is fauna;
                   (b) the act alleged to constitute the offence does not involve
                          anything more than releasing the animal into the wild;
                          and


                                                                          page 19
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 3       Offences against animals

     s. 28



                   (c)   the release occurred in circumstances in which it was
                         reasonable to expect the animal to be able to fend for
                         itself.

     28.         Defence -- where person in charge is not in actual custody
 5         (1)   It is a defence to a charge under section 19(1) committed in
                 circumstances described in section 19(3)(d), (e), (f) or (h) for a
                 person to prove that the person --
                    (a) is a "person in charge" by reason of paragraph (a), (c)
                          or (d), but not paragraph (b), of the definition of that
10                        term; and
                   (b) took reasonable steps to ensure that the animal would be
                          properly treated and cared for.
           (2)   It is a defence to a charge under section 19(1) committed in
                 circumstances described in section 19(3)(d), (e), (f) or (h) for a
15               person to prove that the person --
                    (a) is a "person in charge" by reason only of paragraph (d)
                          of the definition of that term; and
                   (b) did not know, and could not reasonably be expected to
                          have known, that --
20                           (i) the animal was at a place, or in a vehicle, owned
                                  or occupied by the person; or
                            (ii) the animal was not being properly treated and
                                  cared for.

     29.         Defence -- prescribed use of devices
25               It is a defence to a charge under section 19(1) committed in
                 circumstances described in section 19(2)(b) for a person to
                 prove that the person was a prescribed person, or was in a
                 prescribed class of persons, and used the device in a prescribed
                 manner.


     page 20
                                                         Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                             Offences against animals      Part 3

                                                                                 s. 30



     30.         Defence -- prescribed surgical or similar operations,
                 practices and activities
                 It is a defence to a charge under section 19(1) committed in
                 circumstances described in section 19(3)(g) for a person to
 5               prove that the person was a prescribed person, or was in a
                 prescribed class of persons, and carried out the operation,
                 practice or activity in a prescribed manner.

     31.         Possession of things intended to inflict cruelty
           (1)   A person must not be in possession of any thing with the
10               intention of using the thing to inflict cruelty on an animal.
                 Penalty: $10 000 and imprisonment for 6 months.
           (2)   It is a defence to a charge under subsection (1) for a person to
                 prove that the thing was a prescribed thing and that the person
                 was a prescribed person, or was in a prescribed class of persons,
15               in respect of the thing.
           (3)   It is a defence to a charge under subsection (1) for a person to
                 prove that if the person had used the thing on or in relation to an
                 animal the person would have had a defence to a resulting
                 charge under section 19.

20   32.         Shooting, hunting or fighting captive animals
           (1)   A person must not engage in a prohibited activity.
                 Penalty: Minimum -- $1 000.
                          Maximum -- $20 000 and imprisonment for one year.
           (2)   Without limiting subsection (1), a person engages in a
25               prohibited activity if the person --
                   (a) takes part in it;
                   (b) spectates at it;
                   (c) organizes it;

                                                                             page 21
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 3       Offences against animals

     s. 32



                (d)    promotes it;
                (e)    keeps an animal for the purpose of it;
                 (f)   allows it to occur at a place owned or operated by the
                       person; or
 5              (g)    in the case of the activities described in paragraphs (c)
                       and (d) of the definition of "prohibited activity",
                       encourages an animal to participate in it.
        (3)    It is a defence to a charge under subsection (1) for a person to
               prove that the activity the subject of the charge was a prescribed
10             activity.
        (4)    It is a defence to a charge under subsection (1) where the
               activity the subject of the charge is the releasing of an animal
               for the purposes of it being hunted by another animal for a
               person to prove that --
15                (a) the animal was released as food for a predatory animal
                        kept in captivity;
                 (b) the diet of captive predatory animals of that kind
                        ordinarily includes animals of the kind released; and
                  (c) the captive predatory animal will not ordinarily eat dead
20                      meat.
        (5)    In this section --
               "prohibited activity" means an activity that involves releasing
                   an animal, or putting an animal somewhere, for the purpose
                   of enabling the animal to be --
25                 (a) shot at (whether with a firearm or any other weapon);
                   (b) hunted by a person or another animal;
                   (c) fought by a person or another animal; or
                   (d) chased by another animal, other than an animal of the
                         same species.


     page 22
                                                         Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                                           Inspectors      Part 4
                                            Appointment of inspectors Division 1
                                                                             s. 33



                               Part 4 -- Inspectors
                     Division 1 -- Appointment of inspectors
     33.         Appointment of general inspectors
           (1)   The Executive Director is to appoint as general inspectors --
 5                (a) those members of the staff of the RSPCA nominated by
                       the RSPCA; and
                  (b) in accordance with subsection (2), as many other people
                       whom the Executive Director considers to be suitably
                       qualified or experienced as the Executive Director
10                     considers necessary for the purposes of the Act.
           (2)   The Executive Director may appoint under subsection (1)(b) --
                  (a) a member of the staff of --
                          (i) the Department;
                         (ii) Agriculture WA;
15                      (iii) CALM;
                        (iv) Fisheries Western Australia; or
                         (v) a local government,
                       who is nominated by the chief executive officer of that
                       department or local government; or
20                (b) any other person whom the Executive Director considers
                       it appropriate to appoint.
           (3)   The terms of appointment of a general inspector are to be
                 determined by the Executive Director and set out in the
                 instrument of appointment.
25         (4)   An appointment under subsection (1) remains in force for
                 5 years unless before then --
                   (a) the inspector (other than an inspector appointed under
                         subsection (2)(b)) ceases to be a member of the staff of

                                                                           page 23
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 4       Inspectors
     Division 1   Appointment of inspectors
     s. 34



                         the RSPCA or of the department or local government
                         the chief executive officer of which nominated him or
                         her (as the case requires);
                  (b)    the inspector resigns by written notice to the Executive
 5                       Director; or
                   (c)   the appointment is revoked by the Executive Director.
           (5)   The Executive Director may appoint a general inspector as a
                 scientific inspector in relation to schools.

     34.         Appointment of scientific inspectors
10         (1)   The Executive Director is to appoint as many scientific
                 inspectors as are required for the purposes of this Act.
           (2)   The Executive Director may appoint under subsection (1) any
                 person the Executive Director considers to be suitably qualified
                 or experienced.
15         (3)   The terms of appointment of a scientific inspector are to be
                 determined by the Executive Director and set out in the
                 instrument of appointment.
           (4)   An appointment under subsection (1) remains in force for
                 5 years unless before then --
20                 (a) the inspector resigns by written notice to the Executive
                         Director; or
                   (b) the appointment is revoked by the Executive Director.

     35.         Restricted appointments
           (1)   A general inspector who is an employee of a local
25               government --
                   (a) is an inspector only for the district of that local
                        government; and


     page 24
                                                   Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                                     Inspectors      Part 4
                                      Appointment of inspectors Division 1
                                                                       s. 35



            (b)    may only exercise the powers of an inspector outside
                   that district if --
                      (i) the exercise of the power relates to an offence
                           reasonably suspected to have been committed in
 5                         the inspector's district;
                     (ii) the local government of the district where the
                           power is to be exercised has authorized the
                           exercise of the power by the inspector in its
                           district; or
10                  (iii) the inspector considers the situation to be an
                           emergency.
     (2)   The Executive Director may, by written notice, restrict the
           authority of an inspector, other than a police officer, by limiting
           all or any of the following --
15           (a) the functions that may be performed by the inspector;
            (b)    the --
                      (i) places where;
                     (ii) times when;
                    (iii) circumstances in which,
20                 the inspector may perform the inspector's functions.
     (3)   When the authority of an inspector is restricted under
           subsection (2) the functions conferred on the inspector by or
           under this Act are limited to the extent set out in the notice.
     (4)   A restriction under subsection (2) --
25          (a) may be imposed when the inspector is appointed or at a
                   later time; and
            (b) may be varied or cancelled by the Executive Director by
                   written notice to the inspector.



                                                                       page 25
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 4       Inspectors
     Division 2   Functions and powers of inspectors
     s. 36



     36.         Identification card
           (1)   The Executive Director is to issue an identification card to each
                 inspector, other than police officers.
           (2)   An inspector, other than a police officer, must produce his or
 5               her identification card if requested to do so by a person in
                 respect of whom the inspector is about to exercise, is exercising
                 or has exercised, any of the inspector's powers.
           (3)   A person who ceases to be an inspector must, as soon as
                 practicable, return his or her identification card to the Executive
10               Director.

                 Division 2 -- Functions and powers of inspectors
     37.         Functions and powers of inspectors
           (1)   Subject to subsection (3), the functions of a general inspector
                 are --
15                 (a) to enforce Part 3;
                   (b) if the inspector has been appointed under section 33(5)
                        as a scientific inspector in relation to schools, to enforce
                        Part 2 in relation to schools (as defined in the Education
                        Act 1928);
20                 (c) to provide assistance to scientific inspectors if requested
                        under section 48(1); and
                   (d) to provide information and assistance to the Executive
                        Director in relation to matters arising under this Act.
           (2)   The functions of a scientific inspector are --
25                (a) to enforce Part 2;
                  (b) to enforce Part 3 in relation to things done, purported to
                        be done or required under this Act to be done, under a
                        licence;

     page 26
                                                         Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                                           Inspectors      Part 4
                                   Functions and powers of inspectors Division 2
                                                                             s. 38



                  (c)   to provide information and assistance to the Executive
                        Director in relation to matters arising under this Act; and
                  (d)   to provide information and assistance to the Minister in
                        relation to licensing matters.
 5         (3)   Subject to subsection (1)(b) and section 48(3), a general
                 inspector must not exercise the inspector's powers in relation to
                 things done, purported to be done, or required under this Act to
                 be done, under a licence.
           (4)   A scientific inspector may only exercise the inspector's
10               powers in relation to things done, purported to be done, or
                 required under this Act to be done, under a licence.

     38.         Power to enter a place
           (1)   An inspector may enter a place --
                  (a) with the consent of the occupier or person apparently in
15                      charge of the place;
                  (b) if a notice has been given in accordance with
                        subsection (3) and the period specified in the notice as
                        the period within which objections may be made has
                        elapsed with no objection being made;
20                (c) under a warrant issued under section 59;
                  (d) in the case of a place occupied by a scientific
                        establishment, at any time; or
                  (e) in the case of any other non-residential place, if the
                        inspector reasonably suspects that an offence under
25                      Part 3 --
                           (i) has been, or is being, committed at the place; or
                          (ii) is likely to be, or to continue to be, committed at
                                the place if entry is not effected.



                                                                           page 27
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 4       Inspectors
     Division 2   Functions and powers of inspectors
     s. 39



           (2)   In order to enter a place under subsection (1)(b), (c), (d) or (e)
                 an inspector may --
                   (a) use such force as is reasonably necessary; and
                   (b) enter any other non-residential place for the purpose of
 5                       reaching the place to be entered.
           (3)   An inspector wishing to enter a place may give to the owner or
                 occupier of the place a notice --
                   (a) stating that the inspector wishes to enter the place;
                  (b) specifying the purpose for which entry is required; and
10                 (c) specifying the period (being not less than 24 hours)
                        within which the owner or occupier may object to the
                        inspector.
           (4)   Where a notice has been given under subsection (3) and no
                 objection has been made to the inspector within the time
15               specified in the notice --
                   (a) the notice continues to have effect until --
                           (i) the purpose for which entry was required has
                                 been effected; or
                          (ii) 7 days after the end of the objection period
20                               specified in the notice,
                         whichever occurs first; and
                   (b) successive entries for that purpose are to be regarded as
                         entries to which the notice relates.

     39.         Power to enter vehicles
25         (1)   An inspector may enter a vehicle --
                  (a) with the consent of the occupier or person apparently in
                        charge of the vehicle;
                  (b) under a warrant issued under section 59; or


     page 28
                                                         Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                                           Inspectors      Part 4
                                   Functions and powers of inspectors Division 2
                                                                             s. 40



                  (c)   unless the vehicle is a residence, if the inspector
                        reasonably suspects that the vehicle --
                           (i) has been, or is being, used in the commission of
                                an offence under Part 3; or
 5                        (ii) is likely to be, or to continue to be, used in the
                                commission of an offence under Part 3 unless
                                entry is effected.
           (2)   In order to enter a vehicle under subsection (1)(b) or (c) an
                 inspector may --
10                 (a) stop and detain the vehicle for as long as is reasonably
                         necessary;
                   (b) use such force as is reasonably necessary; and
                   (c) enter a non-residential place for the purpose of reaching
                         the vehicle.
15   40.         Care of animals
           (1)   An inspector may --
                  (a) provide to an animal; or
                  (b) direct a person in control of an animal to provide to the
                        animal,
20               any food, water, shelter, care or treatment the inspector
                 considers necessary to ensure the welfare, safety and health of
                 the animal.
           (2)   A person must comply with a direction given under
                 subsection (1)(b).
25               Penalty: $10 000 and imprisonment for 6 months.
     41.         Humane destruction of animals
           (1)   An inspector who reasonably believes an animal is suffering so
                 severely that destroying it would be a humane thing to do, may
                 destroy the animal in a humane manner.

                                                                           page 29
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 4       Inspectors
     Division 2   Functions and powers of inspectors
     s. 42



           (2)   An inspector destroying an animal under subsection (1) must
                 notify --
                   (a) if the animal is fauna, the chief executive officer of
                        CALM; or
 5                 (b) otherwise a person in charge of the animal,
                 of the destruction and the reason for it --
                   (c) if it is reasonable to do so, before destroying the animal;
                         or
                   (d) otherwise, as soon as practicable after destroying the
10                       animal.

     42.         Seizure of animals
           (1)   An inspector may seize an animal --
                  (a) if the inspector reasonably suspects that an offence
                        under Part 3 is being, or has been, committed in respect
15                      of the animal; or
                  (b) under a warrant issued under section 60.
           (2)   An inspector who seizes an animal is to ensure that it is properly
                 treated and cared for (including the provision of veterinary care
                 if that is appropriate) until it is dealt with in accordance with
20               section 44 or 45.

     43.         Seizure of other property
           (1)   An inspector may seize any other thing that the inspector
                 reasonably suspects --
                   (a) is being, or has been, used to commit; or
25                 (b) may afford evidence of the commission of,
                 an offence under this Act.



     page 30
                                                         Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                                           Inspectors      Part 4
                                   Functions and powers of inspectors Division 2
                                                                             s. 44



           (2)   An inspector who seizes anything under subsection (1) is to --
                  (a) keep it in safe custody; and
                  (b) to the extent that it is practicable to do so, maintain it in
                        the condition it was in when it was seized,
 5               until it is dealt with in accordance with section 44.

     44.         Dealing with seized property
           (1)   This section does not apply in relation to a seized animal that is
                 fauna, unless the animal had been lawfully taken under the
                 Wildlife Conservation Act 1950.
10         (2)   As soon as practicable after seizing property an inspector must
                 take reasonable steps to notify the owner or a person in charge
                 of the property that it has been seized and of the owner's rights
                 under subsection (6).
           (3)   An inspector may retain seized property until required by
15               subsection (5), or by an order under subsection (9) or section 55,
                 to return it to the owner or to dispose of it.
           (4)   Subject to an order of a court to the contrary, an inspector may
                 return seized property to the owner at any time if the inspector
                 is satisfied --
20                  (a) that no useful purpose will be served by retaining it; and
                  (b)    in the case of an animal, that it will be properly treated
                         and cared for.
           (5)   Subject to subsection (9), an inspector must return seized
                 property to the owner if --
25                 (a) 4 months have elapsed since it was seized and no person
                        has been charged with a relevant offence; or




                                                                             page 31
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 4       Inspectors
     Division 2   Functions and powers of inspectors
     s. 44



                (b)    a charge of a relevant offence has been heard and
                       determined but the court hearing the charge has made no
                       order as to the return or forfeiture of the property.
        (6)    The owner of seized property may apply to the Local Court for
 5             an order that it be returned.
        (7)    Where an inspector is required by subsection (5) to return seized
               property to the owner the inspector may apply to the Local
               Court for an order that the property remain under seizure.
        (8)    An inspector may apply to the Local Court for an order that the
10             seized property be forfeited to the Crown.
        (9)    On an application under subsection (6), (7) or (8) a court
               may --
                (a) make the order sought on such terms and conditions as
                      the court thinks fit; or
15              (b) refuse to make the order.
       (10)    On an application under subsection (6), (7) or (8) in relation to a
               seized animal the court must have regard to the welfare, safety
               and health of the animal.
       (11)    In this section --
20             "owner", in relation to something that has been seized, means
                    the person from whom the thing was seized or any other
                    person who satisfies the Executive Director that he or she is
                    entitled to possession of the thing;
               "relevant offence" means an offence under this Act --
25                  (a) if the seized property is an animal, the commission of
                           which affected the welfare, safety or health of the
                           animal; or




     page 32
                                                         Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                                           Inspectors      Part 4
                                   Functions and powers of inspectors Division 2
                                                                             s. 45



                      (b)   if the seized property is not an animal --
                               (i) the commission of which involved the use of
                                     the seized property; or
                              (ii) in respect of the commission of which the
 5                                   seized property may afford evidence.

     45.         Dealing with seized fauna
                 An inspector who seizes an animal that is fauna, other than an
                 animal that has been lawfully taken under the Wildlife
                 Conservation Act 1950, is to ensure that the animal is delivered
10               to, or dealt with in accordance with the instructions of, the chief
                 executive officer of CALM.

     46.         Power to require information
           (1)   An inspector who reasonably suspects a person is committing,
                 or has committed, an offence under this Act may ask the person
15               for the person's name, usual place of residence and date of birth.
           (2)   A person must not, without a reasonable excuse, fail to answer a
                 question asked under subsection (1).
                 Penalty: $1 000.

     47.         Other powers of inspectors
20         (1)   Subject to sections 38, 39, 42 and 43, for the purposes of this
                 Act an inspector may --
                  (a) search a place or vehicle;
                  (b) examine and take samples from an animal, place,
                         vehicle or thing;
25                (c) take an animal to a place, or put an animal in a vehicle,
                         for the purpose of performing the inspector's functions
                         in relation to it;


                                                                            page 33
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 4       Inspectors
     Division 2   Functions and powers of inspectors
     s. 47



                (d)    direct a person to take an animal to a specified place, or
                       to put it in a specified vehicle, within a specified time;
                (e)    direct a person not to remove an animal from a specified
                       place or vehicle for a specified period;
 5               (f)   take photographs, video recordings or other recordings
                       of an animal, place, vehicle or thing;
                (g)    take measurements or recordings of any sort;
                (h)    if the inspector reasonably suspects that there is, in a
                       container, an animal or thing that may afford evidence
10                     of the commission of an offence under this Act --
                          (i) require the person apparently in charge of it to
                                open the container; or
                         (ii) if that person is not available to do so, or fails to
                                do so, use reasonable force to break open the
15                              container;
                 (i)   examine, take extracts from or copy (and if necessary
                       remove for the purpose of taking extracts or making
                       copies) a record;
                 (j)   give any directions to a person in control of an animal
20                     that the inspector considers are necessary to protect the
                       welfare, safety and health of the animal;
                (k)    conduct examinations, and make inquiries, that the
                       inspector considers are necessary to check whether this
                       Act is being complied with or to investigate a suspected
25                     offence; and
                 (l)   request a person to assist the inspector in performing the
                       inspector's functions.
        (2)    An inspector exercising, or proposing to exercise, a power under
               this section must, if asked by a person who is or will be affected
30             by the exercise of the power, explain why the inspector is
               exercising the power.

     page 34
                                                          Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                                            Inspectors      Part 4
                                    Functions and powers of inspectors Division 2
                                                                              s. 48



           (3)   A person must comply with a requirement or direction made
                 under subsection (1)(a) to (j).
                 Penalty: $10 000 and imprisonment for 6 months.
           (4)   In subsection (1)(i) --
 5               "record" includes a document, tape, disc or other device or
                      medium on which data is recorded or stored mechanically,
                      photographically, electronically or otherwise.
     48.         Performance of an inspector's functions
           (1)   When performing a function under this Act an inspector may be
10               accompanied or assisted by a person requested by the inspector
                 to assist.
           (2)   A person accompanying or assisting an inspector may exercise a
                 function of the inspector if, and to the extent, authorized by the
                 inspector.
15         (3)   A general inspector accompanying or assisting a scientific
                 inspector under subsection (1) may exercise the general
                 inspector's functions under this Act if, and to the extent,
                 authorized by the scientific inspector.
           (4)   Subject to subsection (5), where an inspector is permitted under
20               this Act to do an act in relation to an animal that is within the
                 definition of "veterinary surgery" as defined in the Veterinary
                 Surgeons Act 1960 the inspector is to ensure that the act is done
                 by a veterinary surgeon.
           (5)   Subsection (4) does not apply to an inspector acting under
25               section 41 if, in the inspector's opinion, it is not reasonable to
                 wait until a veterinary surgeon is able to do the act.
           (6)   When performing a function under this Act an inspector or
                 person assisting an inspector must --
                   (a) take reasonable precautions to avoid the spread of
30                      disease;

                                                                              page 35
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 4       Inspectors
     Division 3   Additional powers of scientific inspectors
     s. 49



                  (b)    cause as little damage as is reasonably practicable to
                         property; and
                   (c)   cause as little disruption as is reasonably practicable to
                         any business or activity that is being carried on in
 5                       accordance with this Act.
             Division 3 -- Additional powers of scientific inspectors
     49.         Direction to suspend use and referral to animal ethics
                 committee
           (1)   A scientific inspector who reasonably suspects a person is using
10               animals for scientific purposes in a manner contrary to --
                   (a) the scientific use code; or
                   (b) the approval given by the relevant animal ethics
                        committee,
                 may refer the matter to the relevant animal ethics committee for
15               reconsideration.
           (2)   If a referral is made under subsection (1) the person using the
                 animal must stop that use until the matter has been approved by
                 the relevant animal ethics committee under subsection (3).
                 Penalty: $10 000 and imprisonment for 6 months.
20         (3)   An animal ethics committee must consider a referral under
                 subsection (1) as if it were an application under the scientific
                 use code made by the person using the animals for approval to
                 use animals for the purpose, and in the manner, referred to in
                 that subsection.
25   50.         Directions to licensees and their staff
           (1)   A scientific inspector who suspects that a licensee has, or any of
                 the staff or students of a licensee have, failed to comply with a
                 condition to which a licence is subject may give any directions the
                 inspector considers necessary or desirable to remedy that failure.

     page 36
                                                      Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                                        Inspectors      Part 4
                        Additional powers of scientific inspectors Division 3
                                                                          s. 50



     (2)   A direction is to be given by a scientific inspector --
            (a) if the inspector considers the failure creates a serious
                  and urgent threat to the welfare, safety or health of an
                  animal, orally to the person who, at that time, has
 5                custody of the animal; or
            (b) otherwise, in writing to the person who failed to comply
                  with the condition.
     (3)   If a direction is given orally a scientific inspector must give a
           written copy of the direction to the person who failed to comply
10         with the condition as soon as practicable, and in any event
           within 24 hours, after giving the oral direction.
     (4)   If the person to whom a direction is given is not the licensee, a
           scientific inspector must give a written copy of the direction to
           the licensee as soon as practicable, and in any event within
15         24 hours, after giving the direction.
     (5)   A direction must include the reasons for giving it.
     (6)   A direction --
            (a) takes effect from the time it is first given; and
            (b) remains in force until it has been complied with or a
20                scientific inspector revokes it by written notice to the
                  licensee.
     (7)   When a direction is in force the licensee and all of the licensee's
           staff and students must comply with it.
           Penalty: $10 000 and imprisonment for 6 months.
25   (8)   It is a defence to a charge under subsection (7) for a member of
           staff or a student to prove that the person did not know of, and
           could not reasonably have been expected to know of, the
           direction.



                                                                       page 37
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 4       Inspectors
     Division 3   Additional powers of scientific inspectors
     s. 51



     51.         Power to require information
           (1)   A scientific inspector who reasonably suspects that a person is
                 using animals for scientific purposes or is carrying on business
                 supplying animals for use for scientific purposes may ask the
 5               person --
                   (a) for the person's name, usual place of residence and date
                        of birth;
                   (b) whether the person is a licensee or a member of the staff
                        or a student of a licensee; and
10                 (c) in the case of a member of staff or a student, for the
                        name and address of the licensee.
           (2)   A person must not, without reasonable excuse, fail to answer
                 truthfully a question asked under subsection (1).
                 Penalty: $1 000.

15   52.         Advice regarding licensing matters
           (1)   A scientific inspector may provide to the Minister written
                 advice on --
                   (a) whether a scientific establishment --
                           (i) has an animal ethics committee; or
20                        (ii) has made arrangements under which the animal
                                 ethics committee for another scientific
                                 establishment will act as its animal ethics
                                 committee;
                   (b) whether, in the inspector's opinion, the facilities and
25                      equipment at a scientific establishment, and the
                        procedures used by a licensee, comply with the
                        scientific use code or any other relevant code of
                        practice;



     page 38
                                                             Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                                               Inspectors      Part 4
                               Additional powers of scientific inspectors Division 3
                                                                                 s. 53



                   (c)   whether, in the inspector's opinion, a licensee has, or
                         any of the staff or students of a licensee have, failed to
                         comply with the scientific use code or any other code of
                         practice compliance with which is a condition of the
 5                       licence; and
                  (d)    other matters relating to a licensee that the inspector
                         considers ought to be brought to the attention of the
                         Minister.
           (2)   The Minister may rely on advice given under subsection (1) to
10               satisfy himself or herself as to a matter referred to in section 9
                 or 17(1) or (2) without further investigation.

     53.         Attendance at meetings of animal ethics committees
           (1)   A scientific inspector may attend a meeting of an animal ethics
                 committee as an observer.
15         (2)   If requested to do so by a scientific inspector an animal ethics
                 committee is to ensure that the inspector is notified of the dates
                 and times when, and the places where, meetings of that
                 committee are to be held.




                                                                              page 39
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 5       Enforcement
     Division 1   Additional court orders
     s. 54



                             Part 5 -- Enforcement
                        Division 1 -- Additional court orders
     54.         Court may order a post mortem
           (1)   A court hearing a charge under this Act may order that a post
 5               mortem be carried out on an animal by a veterinary surgeon
                 specified in the order.
           (2)   If an order is made under subsection (1) --
                   (a) the results of the post mortem are to be given to the
                         court, the prosecutor and the alleged offender; and
10                 (b) the cost of the post mortem is a cost in respect of which
                         an order may be made under section 58.

     55.         Orders additional to penalty
           (1)   A court convicting a person of an offence under this Act may, in
                 addition to imposing a penalty, make any other orders against
15               the offender that the court considers appropriate to protect the
                 welfare, safety and health of an animal, a group of animals or
                 animals in general.
           (2)   Without limiting subsection (1) a court may --
                  (a)    prohibit the offender from --
20                          (i) being in charge of; or
                           (ii) having contact with,
                         a specified animal, an animal of a specified kind, or an
                         animal of any kind --
                          (iii) for a period the court thinks fit (which may be
25                               permanently); and
                          (iv) either absolutely or unless specified conditions
                                 are satisfied;

     page 40
                                             Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                            Enforcement        Part 5
                                  Additional court orders Division 1
                                                                 s. 55



     (b)   order that an animal of which the offender is in
           charge --
              (i) if the animal is fauna that has not been lawfully
                   taken under the Wildlife Conservation Act 1950,
 5                 be delivered to, or dealt with in accordance with
                   the instructions of, the chief executive officer of
                   CALM; or
             (ii) otherwise, be removed to a place the court thinks
                   fit;
10   (c)   order the forfeiture to the Crown of --
              (i) seized property owned by the offender;
             (ii) an animal owned by the offender; or
            (iii) anything used by the offender in the commission
                   of the offence;
15   (d)   order that property seized in relation to the offence be
           returned to the owner of that property;
     (e)   order the humane destruction of an animal that is
           suffering severe harm;
     (f)   order the offender to reimburse a person who incurred
20         costs under section 40(1), 41 or 42 in relation to --
              (i) the animal the subject of the offence; or
             (ii) another animal of which the offender was in
                   charge at the time of the offence and which was
                   provided with care, destroyed or seized because
25                 of the commission of the offence;
     (g)   suspend, revoke or impose conditions on a licence held
           by the offender; and
     (h)   disqualify the offender from obtaining a licence, or a
           licence of a particular kind, for a period the court thinks
30         fit (which may be permanently).


                                                              page 41
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 5       Enforcement
     Division 1   Additional court orders
     s. 56



           (3)   If a licence is suspended or revoked under subsection (2)(g) the
                 offender must deliver the licence to the Minister as soon as
                 practicable, and in any event within 7 days, after the order is
                 made.
 5               Penalty: $1 000.
           (4)   An offender must comply with an order made against him or her
                 under subsection (1).
                 Penalty: $10 000 and imprisonment for 6 months.
           (5)   The court is to ensure that a copy of an order made under
10               subsection (2)(g) or (h) is given to the Executive Director.

     56.         Order for reimbursement of costs
           (1)   A person who has incurred costs under section 40(1), 41 or 42
                 in relation to an animal may apply to the Local Court for an
                 order that the applicant be reimbursed for those costs by a
15               person who was in charge of the animal immediately before the
                 care was provided or the animal was destroyed or seized.
           (2)   On an application under subsection (1) the court is to make the
                 order sought unless the respondent proves that there were no
                 reasonable grounds on which an inspector could have
20               considered the provision of care, destruction or seizure to be
                 necessary.
           (3)   The court may adjourn an application under subsection (1) until
                 after the determination of any relevant prosecution proceedings.
           (4)   If there is more than one person in charge of the animal at the
25               relevant time --
                   (a) the applicant may apply under subsection (1) for an
                          order against any or all of those people;
                   (b) a person against whom an order is sought may join any
                          other of those people as parties to the proceedings; and

     page 42
                                                           Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                                          Enforcement        Part 5
                                                Additional court orders Division 1
                                                                               s. 57



                   (c)   a court making an order under subsection (2) may
                         apportion the costs among so many of those people as are
                         parties to the proceedings in any manner as it thinks fit.
           (5)   An order cannot be made under subsection (1) in respect of
 5               costs for which an order has been made under section 55(2)(f).
           (6)   Costs ordered to be paid under subsection (1) are recoverable in
                 a court of competent jurisdiction as a debt due to the person to
                 whom they are to be paid.
     57.         Order for retention of seized property
10         (1)   A court --
                   (a)   imposing a fine as a penalty for an offence under this
                         Act;
                  (b)    making an order for reimbursement of costs of the kind
                         referred to in section 55(2)(f);
15                 (c)   making an order for reimbursement of costs under
                         section 56; or
                  (d)    making an order for payment of costs under
                         section 58(1),
                 may make an order that seized property owned by the offender
20               or person ordered to pay those costs (as the case requires)
                 remain under seizure until the fine or costs are paid.
           (2)   In an order under subsection (1) a court is to specify --
                   (a) the seized property to which the order relates; and
                   (b) the relevant date for the purposes of subsection (3).
25         (3)   If an order is made under subsection (1) and the fine or costs to
                 which it relates are not paid by the date specified in the order,
                 the seized property to which the order relates is forfeited to the
                 Crown.



                                                                            page 43
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 5       Enforcement
     Division 2   Warrants
     s. 58



     58.         Costs
           (1)   A court hearing proceedings for an offence under this Act or
                 dealing with any other application under this Act may make
                 such orders as to costs as it thinks fit.
 5         (2)   Costs ordered to be paid under subsection (1) are recoverable by
                 the person to whom they are to be paid in a court of competent
                 jurisdiction as a judgment debt due to that person.
                                Division 2 -- Warrants
     59.         Grounds for a search warrant
10               A justice may issue a warrant authorizing an inspector to enter a
                 place or vehicle if satisfied, by complaint made on oath, that --
                   (a) there are reasonable grounds for suspecting that there is
                         at the place or in the vehicle --
                            (i) an animal the welfare, safety or health of which
15                               is under threat; or
                           (ii) anything that may afford evidence of the
                                 commission of an offence under this Act;
                         or
                   (b) entry onto the place or into the vehicle is reasonably
20                       required to investigate a suspected offence.

     60.         Grounds for a warrant to seize animal
                 A justice may issue a warrant authorizing an inspector to seize an
                 animal if satisfied, by complaint made on oath, that there are
                 reasonable grounds for suspecting that an offence under Part 3 is
25               likely to be committed in respect of the animal if it is not seized.

     61.         Form of warrant
                 A warrant is to be in the prescribed form.

     page 44
                                                         Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                                        Enforcement        Part 5
                                                           Warrants   Division 2
                                                                             s. 62



     62.         Urgent warrants
           (1)   If an inspector requires a warrant urgently, or a justice is not
                 available within a reasonable distance of the inspector, the
                 inspector may apply to a justice by telephone, fax, radio, video
 5               conference, electronic mail or another similar method or any
                 combination of those methods as the justice thinks fit.
           (2)   Before applying for a warrant under subsection (1), the
                 inspector must prepare (but need not swear) a complaint setting
                 out the grounds on which the warrant is sought.
10         (3)   A justice who issues a warrant on an application under
                 subsection (1) must --
                   (a) if it is reasonably practicable to do so, send a copy to the
                         inspector by fax or another expedient method (including
                         electronically if that allows the inspector to produce a
15                       written copy of the warrant); or
                   (b) otherwise, inform the inspector of the terms of the
                         warrant, including the dates and times when it was
                         issued and will cease to have effect.
           (4)   An inspector who is informed of the terms of a warrant under
20               subsection (3)(b) must write those terms on a prescribed form of
                 warrant and add the name of the justice.
           (5)   A copy of a warrant sent under subsection (3)(a), or a form of
                 warrant completed in accordance with subsection (4), has effect
                 as a warrant issued by the justice.
25         (6)   As soon as practicable after applying for a warrant under
                 subsection (1) the inspector must swear the complaint and send
                 it to the justice.




                                                                           page 45
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 5       Enforcement
     Division 3   Infringement notices
     s. 63



                        Division 3 -- Infringement notices
     63.         Definition for Division 3
                 In this Division --
                 "authorized person" means a person appointed under
 5                    section 64(1).

     64.         Appointment of authorized persons
           (1)   The RSPCA, the Commissioner of Police and the chief
                 executive officers of --
                   (a) the Department;
10                 (b) Agriculture WA;
                   (c) CALM;
                   (d) Fisheries Western Australia; and
                   (e) every local government,
                 are each to appoint as authorized persons as many members of
15               their staff as are required for the purposes of this Division.
           (2)   A person appointed under subsection (1) by the RSPCA or the
                 Commissioner of Police is an authorized person only in respect
                 of infringement notices given by the RSPCA or the
                 Commissioner of Police respectively.
20         (3)   A person appointed under subsection (1) by the chief executive
                 officer of a department or a local government is an authorized
                 person only in respect of infringement notices given by that
                 department or local government.
           (4)   A person cannot be both an authorized person and an inspector.
25   65.         Giving infringement notices
           (1)   An inspector who reasonably suspects that a person has
                 committed a prescribed offence may give an infringement


     page 46
                                                           Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                                          Enforcement        Part 5
                                                  Infringement notices  Division 3
                                                                               s. 66



                 notice to that person within 28 days of when the offence was
                 allegedly committed.
           (2)   An infringement notice is taken to have been given --
                  (a) if the inspector is a member of staff of the RSPCA, by
 5                       the RSPCA;
                  (b) if the inspector is a police officer, by the Commissioner
                         of Police;
                  (c) if the inspector is a member of staff of a department
                         referred to in section 64(1)(a) to (d), by that department;
10                (d) if the inspector is a member of staff of a local
                         government, by that local government; or
                  (e) if the inspector is any other person, by the Department.

     66.         Content of infringement notice
           (1)   An infringement notice is to be in the prescribed form.
15         (2)   The amount set out as the modified penalty must be the amount
                 prescribed as the modified penalty for the relevant offence at the
                 time the offence was allegedly committed.

     67.         Extension of time to pay
                 An authorized person may extend the period within which an
20               alleged offender may pay the modified penalty even if the time
                 allowed for payment has expired.

     68.         Withdrawal of infringement notice
           (1)   An authorized person may withdraw an infringement notice at
                 any time by sending to the alleged offender a notice in the
25               prescribed form.
           (2)   If an infringement notice is withdrawn after the modified
                 penalty has been paid, the amount paid is to be refunded.

                                                                             page 47
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 5       Enforcement
     Division 4   Review of decisions and appeals
     s. 69



     69.         Benefit of paying modified penalty
           (1)   If --
                   (a)   a modified penalty is paid within 28 days of the notice
                         being given (or any further time allowed under
 5                       section 67); and
                  (b)    the infringement notice has not been withdrawn,
                 the bringing of proceedings, and the imposition of other
                 penalties, in relation to the alleged offence are prevented to the
                 same extent as if the alleged offender had been convicted by a
10               court of, and punished for, the alleged offence.
           (2)   Payment of a modified penalty is not an admission for the
                 purposes of any civil or criminal proceedings.

     70.         Application of modified penalties paid
                 When a modified penalty is paid it is to be dealt with in
15               accordance with section 86 as if it were a fine imposed by a
                 court as a penalty for the alleged offence.

                  Division 4 -- Review of decisions and appeals
     71.         Interpretation for Division 4
           (1)   In this Division --
20               "appealable decision" means a decision made by --
                      (a) the Minister --
                               (i) to decline to issue or renew a licence;
                              (ii) as to the period for which a licence is issued
                                    or renewed;
25                           (iii) as to a condition to which a licence is to be
                                    subject; or


     page 48
                                                          Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                                         Enforcement        Part 5
                                      Review of decisions and appeals  Division 4
                                                                              s. 72



                             (iv)   to suspend or revoke a licence or to disqualify
                                    a person from applying for a licence;
                            or
                      (b)   an inspector to exercise, or as to the manner of
 5                          exercising, a power under --
                               (i) section 40(1)(b) in relation to the provision of
                                   care or treatment;
                              (ii) section 42(1)(a);
                             (iii) section 43(1); or
10                           (iv) section 47(1)(d), (e) or (j).
           (2)   In this Division a reference to the time when a right to object or
                 appeal arose is, in the case of a decision made by --
                   (a) the Minister on a licensing matter, a reference to the
                         time when the applicant or licensee (as the case requires)
15                       received notice of the decision;
                   (b) an inspector, a reference to the time when the power in
                         question was exercised; and
                   (c) the Minister on an objection, the time when the person
                         who made the objection received notice of the decision.

20   72.         Aggrieved person may make an objection
           (1)   A person aggrieved by an appealable decision may object to the
                 decision if the person has not lodged an appeal against the
                 decision.
           (2)   An objection is made by preparing it in the prescribed form and
25               lodging it with the Minister in the prescribed manner within
                 28 days after the right to object arose, or such further time as the
                 Minister may allow.




                                                                             page 49
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 5       Enforcement
     Division 4   Review of decisions and appeals
     s. 73



           (3)   When an objection has been made against a decision, the effect
                 of the decision is suspended until the Minister deals with the
                 objection under section 73(2), unless the Minister directs
                 otherwise.

 5   73.         Dealing with an objection
           (1)   The Minister is to --
                  (a) give the person who made the objection a reasonable
                       opportunity to make submissions in relation to the
                       objection; and
10                (b) deal with the objection as expeditiously as possible.
           (2)   The Minister may --
                  (a) dismiss the objection;
                  (b) vary the decision objected to;
                  (c) revoke the decision objected to and substitute a different
15                     decision; or
                  (d) revoke the decision objected to and refer the matter,
                       with or without directions, to the original decision
                       maker for another decision.
           (3)   The Minister is to give to the person who made the objection
20               written notice of his or her decision and the reasons for it.

     74.         Aggrieved person may appeal
           (1)   A person aggrieved by an appealable decision may appeal
                 against that decision if the person --
                   (a) has not lodged an objection to the decision; or
25                 (b) having lodged an objection, has not been given a notice
                         under section 73(3) at the expiration of 35 days after the
                         objection was lodged.



     page 50
                                                          Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                                         Enforcement        Part 5
                                      Review of decisions and appeals  Division 4
                                                                              s. 75



           (2)   A person who lodged an objection and has been given notice
                 under section 73(3) may appeal against the Minister's decision
                 on the objection.
           (3)   An appeal is made by preparing it in the prescribed form and
 5               lodging it at a Local Court in the prescribed manner, together
                 with the prescribed fee, within 42 days after the right to appeal
                 arose, or such longer period as the court may allow.
           (4)   The appellant is to give a copy of the appeal to the Minister as
                 soon as practicable after the appeal is lodged.
10         (5)   If an appeal has been made against a decision --
                   (a)   of the Minister on a licensing matter or of an inspector,
                         the effect of that decision; or
                  (b)    of the Minister on an objection, the effect of the decision
                         that was the subject of the objection,
15               is suspended until the court deals with the appeal under
                 section 75(4), unless the court orders otherwise.

     75.         Dealing with an appeal
           (1)   A Local Court has jurisdiction to hear and determine an appeal
                 lodged under section 74.
20         (2)   The appeal is to be in the nature of a rehearing unless the court
                 determines otherwise.
           (3)   The appeal proceedings are to be conducted in the manner
                 prescribed by the rules of court, or if no such rules of court are
                 prescribed, in such manner as the court determines.
25         (4)   A court hearing an appeal may --
                  (a) dismiss the appeal;
                  (b) vary the decision appealed against;


                                                                             page 51
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 5       Enforcement
     Division 5   Offences
     s. 76



                   (c)   revoke the decision appealed against and substitute a
                         different decision; or
                  (d)    revoke the decision appealed against and refer the
                         matter, with or without directions, to the original
 5                       decision maker for another decision.
           (5)   A court hearing an appeal may make any orders as to costs as it
                 thinks fit.
           (6)   The clerk of the court is to give written notice of the court's
                 decision and the reasons for it to the appellant, the Minister, the
10               Executive Director, and if the original decision maker was an
                 inspector, that inspector.
           (7)   The decision of a court hearing an appeal under this section is
                 final and effect is to be given to the decision.

                                Division 5 -- Offences
15   76.         Misleading information
                 A person must not give information that the person knows to be
                 false or misleading in a material particular to --
                   (a) the Minister in relation to a licence or an application
                         under Part 2;
20                 (b) an animal ethics committee in relation to an approval of
                         the type referred to in section 6(1)(b); or
                   (c) an inspector exercising a power under this Act, or a
                         person assisting an inspector to exercise a power under
                         this Act.
25               Penalty: $10 000 and imprisonment for 6 months.

     77.         Obstruction of inspectors
                 A person must not hinder, obstruct, abuse or threaten --
                  (a) an inspector exercising a power under this Act; or

     page 52
                                                            Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                                           Enforcement        Part 5
                                                              Offences   Division 5
                                                                                s. 78



                   (b)  a person assisting an inspector to exercise a power under
                        this Act.
                 Penalty: $10 000 and imprisonment for 6 months.
     78.         Pretending to be an inspector
 5               A person must not pretend to be an inspector.
                 Penalty: $10 000 and imprisonment for 6 months.
     79.         Continuing offences
           (1)   If a person commits an offence by reason of --
                   (a) failing to do something that this Act requires to be done;
10                        or
                   (b) doing something that this Act prohibits,
                 that offence is taken to continue until the person does what is
                 required or ceases to do what is prohibited (as the case requires).
           (2)   Where an offence is taken to continue, the offender commits an
15               additional offence on each day during which the offence is
                 taken to continue after written notice of the offence has been
                 given to the offender by an inspector.
                 Penalty: $500 for every day on which the offence is taken to
                      continue.
20   80.         Liability of officers for offence by body corporate or
                 scientific establishments
           (1)   If --
                   (a)   a body corporate; or
                   (b)   a scientific establishment,
25               commits an offence under this Act every person who was an
                 officer of the body or establishment at the time the offence was
                 committed, also commits the offence.

                                                                              page 53
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 5       Enforcement
     Division 5   Offences
     s. 80



        (2)    It is a defence to a charge arising by operation of subsection (1)
               for an officer to prove that --
                  (a) the offence was committed without the officer's consent
                        or connivance; and
 5               (b) the officer exercised all such due diligence to prevent
                        the commission of the offence as the officer ought to
                        have exercised having regard to the officer's functions
                        and to all the circumstances.
        (3)    In this section --
10             "officer" means a person (by whatever name called) who is
                    concerned in, or takes part in, the management of a body
                    corporate or scientific establishment, including --
                    (a) in the case of a body corporate, a director, secretary
                           or executive officer of the body;
15                  (b) in the case of a university, school or other educational
                           institution, a member of the Senate or other
                           governing body of the institution;
                    (c) in the case of a partnership, a partner; and
                    (d) in any case --
20                            (i) a receiver or receiver and manager of the
                                    property of;
                             (ii) any other person who, for the purpose of
                                    enforcing a security, is in possession or
                                    control of the property of;
25                          (iii) a liquidator, official manager or deputy
                                    official manager of; or
                            (iv) a trustee or other person administering a
                                    compromise or arrangement involving,
                           the body corporate or scientific establishment.



     page 54
                                                          Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                                         Enforcement        Part 5
                                                             General   Division 6

                                                                               s. 81


     81.         Partnerships
           (1)   Where a licence is issued for the purposes of a partnership each
                 partner has the same rights and duties as a licensee, whether or
                 not the partner is named on the licence.
 5         (2)   If a licence is issued in respect of a partnership and any of the
                 partners commits an offence under this Act (other than an
                 offence under Part 3 that is unrelated to the activity authorized
                 by the licence) every person who was a partner at the time the
                 offence was committed, commits an offence.
10         (3)   It is a defence to a charge arising by operation of subsection (2)
                 for a person to prove that --
                    (a) the offence was committed without the person's consent
                          or connivance; and
                   (b) the person exercised all such due diligence to prevent
15                        the commission of the offence as the person ought to
                          have exercised having regard to the person's functions
                          and to all the circumstances.

                                Division 6 -- General
     82.         Commencement of proceedings for offences
20         (1)   Proceedings for an offence under this Act may be commenced
                 by --
                   (a)   the Executive Director;
                  (b)    subject to section 37(3) and (4), an inspector; or
                   (c)   an officer of the Department authorized by the
25                       Executive Director.
           (2)   Proceedings for an offence under this Act may not be
                 commenced more than 2 years after the offence was allegedly
                 committed.

                                                                              page 55
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 5       Enforcement
     Division 6   General

     s. 83


           (3)   In proceedings for an offence under this Act, unless evidence is
                 given to the contrary, proof is not required --
                  (a)    of the authority of a person to institute proceedings for
                         the offence; or
 5                (b)    that a signature on a complaint is the signature of a
                         person authorized to commence the proceedings.
           (4)   In proceedings for an offence under this Act an officer of the
                 Department authorized by the Executive Director may appear
                 on behalf of the Executive Director or any other officer of the
10               Department.

     83.         Evidentiary provisions
           (1)   In proceedings for an offence under this Act a certificate
                 purporting to be signed by the Executive Director or the
                 chairman of an animal ethics committee is evidence of the facts
15               stated in the certificate without proof of the appointment or
                 signature of the signatory.
           (2)   A certificate under subsection (1) signed by the Executive
                 Director may state --
                  (a)    that a licence is or is not held by a person;
20                (b)    the conditions to which a licence is subject;
                  (c)    that a licence is or is not in force;
                  (d)    the place to which a licence applies;
                  (e)    that a person is or was a general inspector or a scientific
                         inspector; or
25                 (f)   the day or days on which, or the period during which,
                         anything referred to in paragraphs (a) to (e) applied.




     page 56
                                                         Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                                        Enforcement        Part 5
                                                            General   Division 6

                                                                             s. 84


           (3)   A certificate under subsection (1) signed by the chairman of an
                 animal ethics committee may state --
                   (a) that the use of an animal in a stated manner for scientific
                         purposes is or is not approved by the animal ethics
 5                       committee;
                   (b) that a person is or is not approved by the animal ethics
                         committee to use an animal for scientific purposes;
                   (c) the conditions to which an approval is subject;
                   (d) that an approval is or is not in force;
10                 (e) the place to which an approval applies; or
                    (f) the day or days on which, or period during which,
                         anything referred to in paragraphs (a) to (e) applied.
           (4)   In proceedings under this Act a copy of all or part of a code of
                 practice purporting to be certified by the Executive Director to
15               be a true copy of that code at the relevant time is evidence of
                 that code of practice without proof of the appointment or
                 signature of the Executive Director.
     84.         Breach of code of practice not sufficient to prove cruelty
                 Where a person is charged with an offence under Part 3 the fact
20               that the person has failed to act in accordance with a relevant
                 code of practice --
                   (a) must be taken into consideration by the court; but
                   (b) is not sufficient, on its own, to prove that the person
                         committed the offence.
25   85.         Death of animal not sufficient to prove cruelty
                 Where a person is charged with an offence under Part 3 the fact
                 that the person killed the animal, or did something that
                 contributed to the death of the animal --
                   (a) must be taken into consideration by the court; but


                                                                           page 57
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 5       Enforcement
     Division 6   General

     s. 86


                  (b)   is not sufficient, on its own, to prove that the person
                        committed the offence.

     86.         Application of fines
                 A fine imposed as a penalty for an offence against this Act is to
 5               be paid or credited to, if the offence was prosecuted by --
                   (a) an inspector who is a member of the staff of a local
                         government, that local government; or
                   (b) any other person, the Consolidated Fund.

     87.         Disposal of forfeited property
10         (1)   Property forfeited to the Crown under this Act may be sold,
                 destroyed or otherwise disposed of in the prescribed manner.
           (2)   Proceeds from the sale of forfeited property are to be used --
                   (a) firstly, to pay any unpaid fines payable by the owner of
                        the property;
15                 (b) secondly, to pay any unpaid costs ordered under
                        section 55(2)(f) or 56 to be paid by the owner; and
                   (c) thirdly, to pay any unpaid costs ordered under
                        section 58(1) to be paid by the owner.
           (3)   Any of the proceeds remaining after the application of
20               subsection (2) are to be credited to the Consolidated Fund.

     88.         Penalties for body corporate
                 A body corporate that is convicted of an offence is liable to a
                 penalty of --
                   (a) if a minimum penalty is specified in relation to that
25                       offence, not less than 5 times that minimum penalty; and




     page 58
                                     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                    Enforcement        Part 5
                                        General   Division 6

                                                        s. 88


(b)   in any event, a maximum penalty of not more than
      5 times the maximum penalty specified in relation to
      that offence.




                                                      page 59
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 6       Miscellaneous

     s. 89



                              Part 6 -- Miscellaneous
     89.         General power of Executive Director
                 The Executive Director may take such action as the Executive
                 Director considers appropriate generally to protect and promote
 5               the welfare, safety and health of animals.

     90.         Delegation
           (1)   The Minister may delegate to the Executive Director any of the
                 Minister's functions under this Act other than this power of
                 delegation.
10         (2)   The Executive Director may delegate to any person any of the
                 Executive Director's functions under this Act other than --
                  (a) this power of delegation; or
                  (b) a function delegated by the Minister under
                        subsection (1).
15         (3)   A delegation --
                  (a)   must be made in writing signed by the person making it;
                        and
                  (b)   may delegate a function either generally or as provided
                        in the instrument.

20   91.         Improper use of information
                 A person who performs a function under this Act must not
                 improperly use information acquired in the course of doing
                 so --
                   (a) to gain, directly or indirectly, an advantage for himself
25                      or herself or another person; or
                   (b) to cause detriment to a person.
                 Penalty: $10 000 and imprisonment for 6 months.

     page 60
                                                         Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                                       Miscellaneous       Part 6

                                                                              s. 92



     92.         Protection from liability
           (1)   An action in tort does not lie against a person for anything that
                 the person has, in good faith, done in the performance or
                 purported performance of a function under this Act.
 5         (2)   If this section provides that an action does not lie against a
                 person for doing anything, the RSPCA, a local government of
                 which the person is a member of staff, and the Crown are also
                 relieved of any liability that they might otherwise have had for
                 the doing of the thing by the person.
10         (3)   The protection given by this section applies even though the
                 thing done in the performance or purported performance of a
                 function under this Act may have been capable of being done
                 whether or not this Act had been enacted.
           (4)   A person who, at the request of an inspector, is assisting the
15               inspector to perform a function under this Act is taken, for the
                 purposes of this section, to be performing a function under this
                 Act.
           (5)   In this section a reference to the doing of anything includes a
                 reference to the omission to do anything.

20   93.         Owner may claim compensation for injury or death
           (1)   If the malicious or negligent performance by a scientific
                 inspector of a function under this Act causes an injury to, or the
                 death of, an animal, the owner of the animal is entitled to
                 compensation.
25         (2)   A claim for compensation is to be made to the Minister in the
                 prescribed form and manner within one year of the injury or
                 death.




                                                                            page 61
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 6       Miscellaneous

     s. 93



        (3)    The Minister must --
                (a) if satisfied on reasonable grounds that the owner is
                     entitled under subsection (1) to compensation, accept the
                     claim; or
 5              (b) otherwise, reject the claim.
        (4)    If the Minister accepts a claim the amount of compensation
               payable to the claimant is --
                 (a) the market value of the animal immediately before the
                       injury or death as determined by the Minister; or
10               (b) such lesser amount as the Minister determines to be
                       reasonable in the circumstances (including the extent, if
                       any, to which the owner or another person contributed to
                       the injury or death).
        (5)    Compensation payable under this section is to be paid out of the
15             Consolidated Fund and that Fund is appropriated accordingly by
               this section.
        (6)    If a person is entitled to compensation under this section no
               amount is payable (other than under this section) to any person
               as compensation for the value of the animal.
20      (7)    In this section --
               "caused", in relation to an injury to, or the death of, an animal,
                    means --
                    (a) significantly contributed to the injury to, or the death
                           of, the animal; or
25                  (b) in the case of an animal that was destroyed --
                           significantly contributed to, or significantly
                           exacerbated, the condition of the animal which
                           necessitated its destruction.




     page 62
                                                         Animal Welfare Bill 1999
                                                       Miscellaneous       Part 6

                                                                              s. 94



     94.         Regulations
           (1)   The Governor may make regulations prescribing all matters that
                 are permitted to be prescribed, or that are necessary or
                 convenient to be prescribed to give effect to the purposes of this
 5               Act.
           (2)   Without limiting subsection (1) regulations made under this
                 section may --
                   (a) provide that a contravention of a regulation is an offence
                         and provide a penalty not exceeding $10 000;
10                 (b) exempt a specified person, or specified class of persons,
                         from the requirements of all or any of the provisions of
                         this Act;
                   (c) provide for all or any of the provisions of this Act not to
                         apply in relation to a specified animal or a specified
15                       class of animals;
                   (d) adopt codes of practice relating to the use, care, welfare,
                         safety or health of animals either --
                            (i) as modified by the regulations;
                           (ii) as they exist at a particular date; or
20                        (iii) as they are amended from time to time;
                         and
                   (e) prescribe the matters in respect of which fees are
                         payable under this Act, the amount of those fees, and the
                         persons who are to pay them.




                                                                           page 63
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 7       Repeal, consequential amendments and transitional provisions

     s. 95



           Part 7 -- Repeal, consequential amendments and
                        transitional provisions
     95.         Act repealed
                 The Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act 1920 is repealed.

 5   96.         Fish Resources Management Act 1994 amended
           (1)   The amendments in this section are to the Fish Resources
                 Management Act 1994*.
                 [* Act No. 53 of 1994.
                    For subsequent amendments see 1998 Index to Legislation of
10                  Western Australia, Table 1, pp. 95-6.]
           (2)   After section 191 the following section is inserted --
     "
             191A.    Additional powers of fisheries officers in relation to
                      cruelty
15                    A fisheries officer may, for the purpose of enforcing
                      regulations made under section 258(va), exercise the
                      powers conferred by the Animal Welfare Act 1999 on
                      general inspectors under that Act as if --
                        (a) the fisheries officer was such an inspector;
20                      (b) fish were animals for all purposes under that
                              Act; and
                        (c) an offence under those regulations was an
                              offence under Part 3 of that Act.
                                                                                 ".




     page 64
                                                      Animal Welfare Bill 1999
      Repeal, consequential amendments and transitional provisions      Part 7

                                                                                s. 97



           (3)   After section 258(v) the following paragraphs are inserted --
                     "
                         (va)   prescribe measures to --
                                   (i) prevent cruelty to fish; and
 5                                (ii) provide for the welfare, safety and
                                        health of fish;
                         (vb)   provide for the adoption of codes of practice
                                relating to the use, care, welfare, safety or
                                health of fish either --
10                                 (i) as modified by the regulations;
                                  (ii) as they exist at a particular date; or
                                 (iii) as they are amended from time to time;
                                                                                      ".
     97.         Wildlife Conservation Act 1950 amended
15         (1)   The amendments in this section are to the Wildlife Conservation
                 Act 1950*.
                 [* Reprinted as at 20 November 1998.]
           (2)   After section 15(2)(c) the following paragraph is inserted --
                     "
20                       (ca)   The Minister may, by written notice given to the
                                holder of a licence, cancel a licence or suspend it
                                for such period as the Minister thinks fit if --
                                   (i) the holder of the licence is convicted of
                                       an offence under the Animal Welfare
25                                     Act 1999; or
                                  (ii) a licence under that Act held by the
                                       holder of the licence is suspended or
                                       revoked.
                                                                                      ".


                                                                              page 65
     Animal Welfare Bill 1999
     Part 7       Repeal, consequential amendments and transitional provisions

     s. 98



           (3)       Section 16 is amended as follows:
                      (a) in subsections (1) and (2) by deleting "A person" and
                            inserting instead --
                            " Subject to subsection (3), a person ";
 5                    (b) after subsection (2) by inserting the following
                            subsection --
                 "
                     (3)   Despite subsections (1) and (2) an inspector under the
                           Animal Welfare Act 1999, or a person assisting an
10                         inspector under that Act may --
                             (a) destroy fauna if that is permitted under
                                  section 41 of that Act;
                             (b) be in possession of fauna that has been seized
                                  under that Act for such period as is reasonably
15                                necessary for the person to comply with
                                  section 45 of that Act;
                                                                                      ".

     98.             Transitional
                     Until the expiry of 3 years from the day on which this Act
20                   comes into operation the reference in section 9(2)(b) to "this
                     Act" includes a reference to the Prevention of Cruelty to
                     Animals Act 1920.




     page 66
                                                                            Animal Welfare Bill 1999



                                                                                              Defined Terms



                                      Defined Terms
      [This is a list of terms defined and the provisions where they are defined.
                             The list is not part of the law.]
Defined Term                                                                                       Provision(s)
Agriculture WA................................................................................................ 5
animal .............................................................................................................. 5
animal ethics committee ................................................................................... 5
appealable decision ....................................................................................71(1)
authorized person ........................................................................................... 63
CALM ............................................................................................................. 5
caused ........................................................................................................93(7)
code of practice ................................................................................................ 5
Department ...................................................................................................... 5
Executive Director ........................................................................................... 5
fauna................................................................................................................ 5
field site .....................................................................................................14(2)
Fisheries Western Australia .............................................................................. 5
general inspector .............................................................................................. 5
harm ................................................................................................................ 5
inspector .......................................................................................................... 5
licence.............................................................................................................. 5
non-residential place......................................................................................... 5
officer ........................................................................................................80(3)
owner.......................................................................................................44(11)
person in charge ............................................................................................... 5
pest ............................................................................................................24(2)
place ................................................................................................................ 5
prohibited activity ......................................................................................32(5)
record.........................................................................................................47(4)
relevant offence........................................................................................44(11)
RSPCA ............................................................................................................ 5
scientific establishment..................................................................................... 5
scientific inspector ........................................................................................... 5
scientific purposes ............................................................................................ 5
scientific use code ............................................................................................ 5
staff.................................................................................................................. 5
stock ..........................................................................................................26(2)
vehicle ............................................................................................................. 5
veterinary surgeon ............................................................................................ 5



                                                                                                           page 67

 


[Index] [Search] [Download] [Related Items] [Help]