New South Wales Bills New South Wales Bills[Index] [Search] [Download] [Related Items] [Help]
This is a Bill, not an Act. For current law, see the Acts databases.
New South Wales
Criminal Assets Recovery Amendment
Bill 2009
Contents
Page
1 Name of Act 2
2 Commencement 2
Schedule 1 Amendment of Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990
No 23 3
Schedule 2 Amendment of Confiscation of Proceeds of Crime Act
1989 No 90 16
I certify that this public bill, which originated in the Legislative Assembly, has
finally passed the Legislative Council and the Legislative Assembly of New
South Wales.
Clerk of the Legislative Assembly.
Legislative Assembly,
Sydney, , 2009
New South Wales
Criminal Assets Recovery Amendment
Bill 2009
Act No , 2009
An Act to amend the Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990 and the Confiscation of
Proceeds of Crime Act 1989 with respect to applications for restraining orders,
former restraining orders and assets forfeiture orders; and for other purposes.
I have examined this bill and find it to correspond in all respects with the bill as
finally passed by both Houses.
Assistant Speaker of the Legislative Assembly.
Clause 1 Criminal Assets Recovery Amendment Bill 2009
The Legislature of New South Wales enacts:
1 Name of Act
This Act is the Criminal Assets Recovery Amendment Act 2009.
2 Commencement
This Act commences on the date of assent to this Act.
Page 2
Criminal Assets Recovery Amendment Bill 2009
Amendment of Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990 No 23 Schedule 1
Schedule 1 Amendment of Criminal Assets
Recovery Act 1990 No 23
[1] Section 4 Definitions
Omit "made under section 10 and in force" from the definition of restraining
order in section 4 (1).
Insert instead "made under section 10A and in force".
[2] Section 4 (1), definition of "rules of court"
Omit "made under the Supreme Court Act 1970".
Insert instead "of the Supreme Court".
[3] Sections 1010D
Omit sections 1010B. Insert instead:
10 Nature of "restraining order"
A restraining order is an order that no person is to dispose of or
attempt to dispose of, or to otherwise deal with or attempt to
otherwise deal with, an interest in property to which the order
applies except in such manner or in such circumstances (if any)
as are specified in the order.
10A Proceedings for restraining orders
(1) Application for order
The Commission may apply to the Supreme Court, ex parte, for
a restraining order in respect of:
(a) specified interests, a specified class of interests or all the
interests, in property of a person suspected of having
engaged in a serious crime related activity or serious crime
related activities, including interests acquired after the
making of the order and before the making of an assets
forfeiture order affecting the interests that are subject to
the restraining order, or
(b) specified interests, or a specified class of interests, in
property that are interests of any other person, or
(c) interests referred to in both paragraphs (a) and (b).
(2) The Commission may apply to the Supreme Court, ex parte, for
a restraining order in respect of specified interests, or a specified
class of interests, in property that are held in a false name.
Page 3
Criminal Assets Recovery Amendment Bill 2009
Schedule 1 Amendment of Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990 No 23
(3) The Commission may only apply for a restraining order that
relates to interests in property derived from external serious
crime related activity if the person who has the interests is
domiciled in New South Wales or the property is situated in New
South Wales.
(4) Notice to affected person of application
Despite the application for a restraining order being made ex
parte, the Supreme Court may, if it thinks fit, require the
Commission to give notice of the application to a person who the
Court has reason to believe has a sufficient interest in the
application. A person who is required to be notified is entitled to
appear and adduce evidence at the hearing of the application.
(5) Determination of applications
The Supreme Court must make a restraining order if the
application for the order is supported by an affidavit of an
authorised officer stating that:
(a) in the case of an application in respect of an interest
referred to in subsection (1) (a)--the authorised officer
suspects that the person has engaged in a serious crime
related activity or serious crime related activities and
stating the grounds on which that suspicion is based, and
(b) in the case of an application in respect of an interest
referred to in subsection (1) (b)--the authorised officer
suspects that the interest is serious crime derived property
because of a serious crime related activity or serious crime
related activities of a person and stating the grounds on
which that suspicion is based, and
(c) in the case of an application in respect of an interest
referred to in subsection (2)--the authorised officer
suspects that the interest is fraudulently acquired property
that is illegally acquired property and stating the grounds
on which that suspicion is based,
and the Court considers that, having regard to the matters
contained in any such affidavit and any evidence adduced under
subsection (4), there are reasonable grounds for any such
suspicion.
(6) The Supreme Court may grant an application under this section
for a restraining order for interests in property derived from
external serious crime related activity only if the application is
supported by an affidavit of an authorised officer stating that the
officer has made due enquiry and is satisfied that no action has
been taken under a law of the Commonwealth or any place
Page 4
Criminal Assets Recovery Amendment Bill 2009
Amendment of Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990 No 23 Schedule 1
outside this State (including outside Australia) against any
interests in property of the person concerned that are the subject
of the application as a result of the external serious crime related
activity.
(7) Undertakings by State as to costs or damages
The Supreme Court may refuse to make a restraining order if the
State refuses or fails to give to the Court such undertakings as the
Court considers appropriate as to the payment of damages or
costs, or both, in relation to the making and operation of the
order.
(8) For the purposes of an application for a restraining order, the
Commission may, on behalf of the State, give to the Supreme
Court such undertakings as to the payment of damages or costs,
or both, as the Court requires.
(9) Urgent applications by telephone or other means of
communication
An authorised officer may, on behalf of the Commission, apply
for a restraining order by telephone, radio, facsimile, email or
other means of communication if the application is supported by
a statement of the officer that:
(a) the order is required urgently as there is a risk that funds in
a specified financial institution (being an interest in
property in respect of which the order is sought) may be
withdrawn or transferred to a place outside New South
Wales (including outside Australia), and
(b) it is not practicable for the authorised officer to appear in
person.
(10) If it is not possible for the application to be made directly to the
Supreme Court by the applicant, the application may be
transmitted to the Supreme Court by another person on behalf of
the applicant.
10B Contents and effect of restraining orders
(1) A restraining order does not apply to an interest in property
acquired after the order is made unless the order expressly
provides that it does so apply.
(2) The Supreme Court may, when it makes a restraining order and
if it considers that the circumstances so require, order the NSW
Trustee and Guardian to take control of some or all of the
interests in property that are interests to which the restraining
order applies.
Page 5
Criminal Assets Recovery Amendment Bill 2009
Schedule 1 Amendment of Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990 No 23
(3) A restraining order may, at the time it is made or a later time,
provide for meeting out of the property, or a specified part of the
property, to which the order applies all or any of the following:
(a) the reasonable living expenses of any person whose
interests in property are subject to the restraining order
(including the reasonable living expenses of any
dependants),
(b) subject to section 16A, the reasonable legal expenses of
any person whose interests in property are subject to the
restraining order, being expenses incurred in connection
with the application for the restraining order or an
application for a confiscation order, or incurred in
defending a criminal charge.
(4) A restraining order that is in force in respect of an interest of a
person in property does not prevent:
(a) the levying or execution against the property in
satisfaction, or partial satisfaction, of the debt arising
under a proceeds assessment order in force against the
person, or
(b) with the consent of the Supreme Court, the sale or other
disposition of the interest to enable the proceeds to be
applied in satisfaction or partial satisfaction of that debt, or
(c) with the consent of the Supreme Court, the application of
the interest in satisfaction or partial satisfaction of that
debt.
10C Review of restraining orders
(1) The Supreme Court may, on the application of a person whose
interest in property is affected by a restraining order, set aside the
order on any of the following grounds:
(a) that, having regard to the affidavit supporting the
restraining order application and any other evidence
adduced, the Commission has failed to satisfy the Court
that there are reasonable grounds for the relevant suspicion
referred to in section 10A (5),
(b) that the applicant has established that the order was
obtained illegally or against good faith.
(2) An application under this section by a person is to be made not
later than 28 days after the person is notified of the order or may
be made at any time with the leave of the Supreme Court.
Page 6
Criminal Assets Recovery Amendment Bill 2009
Amendment of Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990 No 23 Schedule 1
(3) If an application is made under this section, the restraining order
concerned remains in force unless and until an order is made by
the Supreme Court to set aside the order.
(4) A person who applies for an order is entitled to adduce evidence
at the application.
10D Duration of restraining orders
(1) After the first 2 working days of its operation, a restraining order
remains in force in respect of an interest in property only while:
(a) there is an application for an assets forfeiture order
pending before the Supreme Court in respect of the
interest, or
(b) there is an unsatisfied proceeds assessment order in force
against the person whose suspected serious crime related
activities formed the basis of the restraining order, or
(c) there is an application for such a proceeds assessment
order pending before the Supreme Court, or
(d) it is the subject of an order of the Supreme Court under
section 20.
(2) A restraining order ceases to be in force if it is set aside under
section 10C.
[4] Section 14 Supreme Court may order sale
Insert "and a restraining order is in force" after "an assets forfeiture order" in
section 14 (1).
[5] Section 22 Making of assets forfeiture order
Omit section 22 (1)(2). Insert instead:
(1) The Commission may apply to the Supreme Court for an order
forfeiting to, and vesting in, the Crown specified interests, a
specified class of interests or all the interests, in property of a
person (an assets forfeiture order).
(1A) The application must specify that the interest in property is an
interest in property of any one or more of the following kinds:
(a) an interest in property of a person suspected by an
authorised officer, at the time of the application, of having
engaged in a serious crime related activity or serious crime
related activities,
(b) an interest in property suspected by an authorised officer,
at the time of the application, of being serious crime
Page 7
Criminal Assets Recovery Amendment Bill 2009
Schedule 1 Amendment of Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990 No 23
derived property because of a serious crime related activity
or serious crime related activities of a person,
(c) an interest in property held in a false name that is suspected
by an authorised officer, at the time of the application, to
be fraudulently acquired property that is illegally acquired
property.
(1B) An assets forfeiture order may be made whether or not an
application for a restraining order relating to the interests in
property the subject of the application for the assets forfeiture
order has been made or granted.
(2) The Supreme Court must make an assets forfeiture order in
respect of an interest in property referred to in subsection (1A) (a)
or (b) if the Court finds it to be more probable than not that the
person whose suspected serious crime related activity, or serious
crime related activities, formed the basis of the application for the
assets forfeiture order was, at any time not more than 6 years
before the making of the application, engaged in:
(a) a serious crime related activity involving an indictable
quantity, or
(b) a serious crime related activity involving an offence
punishable by imprisonment for 5 years or more.
[6] Section 25 Exclusion of property from restraining order and assets
forfeiture order
Insert "or 31D" after "section 12" in section 25 (7).
[7] Section 25 (8)
Insert after section 25 (7):
(8) An application may be made by a person under this section
whether or not the person has also made an application under
section 10C and whether or not any such application is
successful.
[8] Section 31 Charge on property
Omit "section 10 (8) (b)" from section 31 (2) (d).
Insert instead "section 10B (4) (b)".
Page 8
Criminal Assets Recovery Amendment Bill 2009
Amendment of Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990 No 23 Schedule 1
[9] Part 3, Division 2B
Insert after Division 2A:
Division 2B Ancillary orders relating to confiscation
orders
31D Additional orders where application made for confiscation order
(1) If an application is made for a confiscation order, the Supreme
Court may, on application by the Commission, when the
application for the confiscation order is made or at a later time,
make any one or more of the following orders:
(a) an order for the examination on oath of:
(i) the affected person, or
(ii) another person,
before the Court, or before an officer of the Court
prescribed by rules of court, concerning the affairs of the
affected person, including the nature and location of any
property in which the affected person has an interest,
(b) an order for the examination on oath of a person who is the
spouse or a de facto partner of the affected person, before
the Court or before an officer of the Court prescribed by
rules of court, concerning the affairs of the person,
including the nature and location of any property in which
the person or that affected person has an interest,
(c) an order directing a person who is or was an affected
person or, if the affected person is or was a body corporate,
a director of the body corporate specified by the Court, to
furnish to the Commission, within a period specified in the
order, a statement, verified by the oath of the person
making the statement, setting out such particulars of the
property, or dealings with the property, in which the
affected person has or had an interest as the Court thinks
proper.
(2) The Commission must give notice of an application for an order
under this section to the affected person.
(3) Sections 13 and 13A apply in respect of a person being examined
under an order under this section in the same way as they apply
in respect of a person being examined under an order under
section 12 (1).
Page 9
Criminal Assets Recovery Amendment Bill 2009
Schedule 1 Amendment of Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990 No 23
(4) In this section:
affected person means:
(a) in the case of an application for an assets forfeiture order,
the owner of an interest in property that is proposed to be
subject to the order, or
(b) in the case of an application for a proceeds assessment
order, the person who is proposed to be subject to the
order.
[10] Section 52B Effect of registration of interstate restraining orders
Omit "section 10 (3)" wherever occurring. Insert instead "section 10A".
[11] Section 52B (2)
Omit "other than section 10". Insert instead "other than sections 1010D".
[12] Section 54 Proof of certain matters
Insert "or 31D" after "section 12" in section 54 (5).
[13] Schedule 1 Savings and transitional provisions
Insert at the end of clause 1 (1):
Criminal Assets Recovery Amendment Act 2009
[14] Schedule 1, Part 4
Insert after Part 3:
Part 4 Criminal Assets Recovery Amendment Act
2009
15 Definitions
In this Part:
ancillary order means:
(a) an order purported to be made before 12 November 2009
under section 10 (4) or (5), 12 (1) (a), (c), (c1), (d) or (e)
or 17 (as in force when the order was purported to be
made) in respect of a former restraining order, and
(b) any order for costs associated with a former restraining
order or any order referred to in paragraph (a).
current former restraining order means a former restraining
order that had not ceased to be in force before 12 November
2009, other than because of the invalidity of section 10 (as
Page 10
Criminal Assets Recovery Amendment Bill 2009
Amendment of Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990 No 23 Schedule 1
purported to be in force immediately before that date) on
constitutional grounds.
Note. A former restraining order includes an ancillary order.
existing assets forfeiture order means an assets forfeiture order
made under section 22 before the commencement of the 2009
Act.
existing forfeiture application means an application for an assets
forfeiture order that was pending immediately before
12 November 2009 and that was not dismissed or discontinued
for any reason before the commencement of the 2009 Act.
existing interstate restraining order means an interstate
restraining order registered under this Act immediately before the
commencement of the 2009 Act.
former restraining order means an order purported to be made
under section 10 (3) or (3A) of this Act before 12 November
2009, and includes any ancillary order.
restraining provisions means provisions given effect to by
clause 16 (1).
State means the Crown within the meaning of the Crown
Proceedings Act 1988, and includes an officer, employee or agent
of the Crown.
2009 Act means the Criminal Assets Recovery Amendment Act
2009.
16 Current former restraining orders
(1) The provisions of a current former restraining order, as purported
to be in force before 12 November 2009, have effect by force of
this clause on and from the date on which the order was purported
to be made or otherwise purported to take effect.
(2) This Act and any other law apply to or in respect of restraining
provisions in the same way that they apply to or in respect of a
restraining order or ancillary order of the same kind made under
this Act.
(3) Without limiting subclause (2), restraining provisions cease to
have effect, in accordance with this Act, as if they were a
restraining order or ancillary orders of the same kind made by the
Supreme Court under this Act.
(4) Any thing done or omitted to be done under this Act or any other
law in respect of a current former restraining order or any interest
in property purported to be subject to a current former restraining
order is taken to have been done or omitted in respect of the
Page 11
Criminal Assets Recovery Amendment Bill 2009
Schedule 1 Amendment of Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990 No 23
corresponding restraining provisions or interest in property
subject to those provisions.
(5) This clause does not give effect to the provisions of any order that
is set aside or discharged by a court after 12 November 2009 (for
any reason) and before the date of introduction into Parliament of
the Bill for the 2009 Act in respect of any period after the order
was set aside or discharged.
(6) This clause does not apply to the specific restraining orders the
subject of proceedings in the Court of Appeal in International
Finance Trust Company Limited & Anor v New South Wales
Crime Commission [2008] NSWCA 291.
17 Applications to set aside restraining provisions
(1) Restraining provisions may be the subject of an application under
section 10C. Any such application must be made not later than
28 days after the commencement of the 2009 Act.
(2) An application under section 10C in respect of restraining
provisions may relate to the circumstances of the grant of the
current former restraining order concerned.
(3) Despite subclause (2), the following matters may not be the basis
of an application to the Supreme Court to set aside restraining
provisions:
(a) that the affidavit on which the current former restraining
order was based contained evidence that was inadmissible,
(b) that the judge who determined the application for the
current former restraining order failed to supply reasons
for the determination,
(c) that the current former restraining order was invalid
because of the invalidity of section 10 (as purported to be
in force immediately before 12 November 2009) on
constitutional grounds.
Note. The restraining provisions have effect because of
clause 16 (1) and are not orders of the Supreme Court.
(4) The Supreme Court may, at any time on the application of the
Commission, make an order setting aside restraining provisions.
18 No compensation for actions relating to former restraining orders
and existing assets forfeiture orders
(1) This clause excludes liability, or compensation, or relief, only if
the liability or claim for compensation or relief arises wholly or
partly (whether directly or indirectly) from the determination by
Page 12
Criminal Assets Recovery Amendment Bill 2009
Amendment of Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990 No 23 Schedule 1
the High Court in International Finance Trust Company Limited
v New South Wales Crime Commission [2009] HCA 49
(12 November 2009) of the invalidity, on constitutional grounds,
of section 10 of this Act (as purported to be in force immediately
before 12 November 2009).
(2) The State does not incur any liability, and compensation is not
payable by or on behalf of the State, arising directly or indirectly
from any of the following matters:
(a) the enactment of the 2009 Act,
(b) the operation or enforcement of, or compliance with, a
former restraining order or an existing assets forfeiture
order,
(c) the operation or enforcement of this Act or any other law,
or the exercise by any person of a function under this Act
or any other law, in respect of any such order or any
interest in property subject to such an order,
(d) any statement or conduct relating to a former restraining
order or any interest in property subject to such an order
that would have been lawful if the former restraining order
were in force,
(e) the payment of any fees to the NSW Trustee and Guardian
in respect of the exercise of functions relating to a former
restraining order or an existing assets forfeiture order,
(f) without limiting paragraph (b) or (c), the imposition of any
penalty (whether civil or criminal) as a result of the
enforcement of a former restraining order or an existing
assets forfeiture order,
(g) without limiting paragraph (b) or (c), any undertakings as
to damages given in relation to former restraining orders or
existing assets forfeiture orders.
(3) No proceedings may be instituted against the State for
compensation or other relief, whether arising at law or in equity,
for the purpose of:
(a) restraining any action in relation to an interest in property
in accordance with a former restraining order or an
existing assets forfeiture order, or
(b) obtaining compensation for loss or damage arising directly
or indirectly from a matter referred to in subclause (2).
(4) This clause applies to or in respect of any act, statement or
conduct whether occurring before or after the commencement of
this clause.
Page 13
Criminal Assets Recovery Amendment Bill 2009
Schedule 1 Amendment of Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990 No 23
(5) In this clause:
compensation includes damages or costs or any other form of
compensation (whether or not monetary).
conduct includes any act or omission, whether unconscionable,
misleading, deceptive or otherwise.
former restraining order includes an existing interstate
restraining order.
statement includes a representation of any kind:
(a) whether made verbally or in writing, and
(b) whether negligent, false, misleading or otherwise.
(6) This clause has effect despite any provision of this Act or any
other law.
19 Existing assets forfeiture orders
(1) An existing assets forfeiture order is not invalid merely because
there was no valid restraining order in force when the application
for the existing assets forfeiture order was made or when the
existing assets forfeiture order was made.
(2) The validity of an existing assets forfeiture order is not subject to
challenge in any court on the ground that there was no valid
restraining order in force when the application for the existing
assets forfeiture order was made or when the existing assets
forfeiture order was made.
(3) Any act or omission with respect to an existing assets forfeiture
order or property affected by such an order done or omitted
before the commencement of the 2009 Act is taken to have been
validly done or omitted, if it would have been valid if it had been
done or omitted after that commencement.
20 Existing applications for assets forfeiture orders
(1) An existing forfeiture application is taken to have been validly
made and may be granted by the Supreme Court under section 22
whether or not a restraining order is made in respect of interests
in property the subject of the application.
(2) An application made under section 14 relating to an existing
forfeiture application, and not determined before the date of
assent to the 2009 Act, is taken to have been validly made and
may be granted by the Supreme Court.
(3) Nothing in subclause (1) prevents an application being made for
a restraining order in respect of an interest in property that is the
subject of an existing forfeiture application.
Page 14
Criminal Assets Recovery Amendment Bill 2009
Amendment of Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990 No 23 Schedule 1
21 Interstate restraining orders
(1) This Act (other than sections 1010D, as inserted by the 2009
Act) applies, and is taken to have always applied, to an existing
interstate restraining order on registration under this Act as if it
were a restraining order made under section 10A (as substituted
by the 2009 Act).
(2) Any act or omission with respect to an existing interstate
restraining order or property affected by such an order done or
omitted before the commencement of the 2009 Act is taken to
have been validly done or omitted, if it would have been valid if
it had been done or omitted after that commencement.
22 Contraventions of former restraining orders and other offences
relating to former restraining orders
A person is not, because of clause 16, liable to prosecution for
any act or omission if the act or omission did not, at the time it
occurred, constitute an offence.
23 Recordings and caveats
The Commission is not required to take action under
section 15 (4) in respect of a current former restraining order
merely because of the effect on that order of the invalidity of
section 10 (as purported to be in force immediately before
12 November 2009) on constitutional grounds.
24 Regulations
Regulations under clause 1 may have effect despite any provision
of this Part.
Page 15
Criminal Assets Recovery Amendment Bill 2009
Schedule 2 Amendment of Confiscation of Proceeds of Crime Act 1989 No 90
Schedule 2 Amendment of Confiscation of Proceeds
of Crime Act 1989 No 90
[1] Section 43 Restraining orders
Insert "and any evidence adduced under section 44 (1) (b)" after "affidavit"
wherever occurring in section 43 (2) (b) and (4) (b).
[2] Section 44A
Insert after section 44:
44A Powers of Supreme Court to set aside or vary restraining orders
not affected
Nothing in this Act prevents the application of the powers of the
Supreme Court, whether conferred on the Court by rules of the
Court or under any other law, to set aside or vary a restraining
order or any other order under section 43 or 45.
[3] Schedule 1 Savings, transitional and other provisions
Insert at the end of clause 2 (1):
Criminal Assets Recovery Amendment Act 2009
Page 16
[Index] [Search] [Download] [Related Items] [Help]