AustLII [Home] [Databases] [WorldLII] [Search] [Feedback]

Federal Court of Australia

You are here:  AustLII >> Databases >> Federal Court of Australia >> 2011 >> [2011] FCA 899

[Database Search] [Name Search] [Recent Decisions] [Noteup] [Download] [Help]

Pattison (Trustee), in the matter of Abdulrahman (Bankrupt) (No 2) [2011] FCA 899 (8 July 2011)

Last Updated: 9 August 2011

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA


Pattison (Trustee), in the matter of Abdulrahman (Bankrupt) (No 2)

[2011] FCA 899


Citation:
Pattison (Trustee), in the matter of Abdulrahman (Bankrupt) (No 2) [2011] FCA 899


Parties:
PAUL ANTHONY PATTISON (AS TRUSTEE OF THE BANKRUPT ESTATES OF MOHAMED ABDULRAHMAN AND OTHERS (AS PER ANNEXURE “A”))


File number:
VID 644 of 2011


Judge:
NORTH J


Date of judgment:
8 July 2011


Date of hearing:
8 July 2011


Place:
Melbourne


Division:
GENERAL DIVISION


Category:
No Catchwords


Number of paragraphs:
12


Counsel for the Applicant:
Mr G Bigmore QC


Solicitor for the Applicant:
Saxbys Lawyers


Counsel for the Inspector General:
Ms C Gobbo


Solicitor for the Inspector General:
Australian Government Solicitor

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION
VID 644 of 2011

IN THE MATTER OF MOHAMED ABDULRAHMAN AND OTHERS (AS PER ANNEXURE “A”)



PAUL ANTHONY PATTISON (AS TRUSTEE OF THE BANKRUPT ESTATES OF MOHAMED ABDULRAHMAN AND OTHERS (AS PER ANNEXURE “A”))
Applicant

JUDGE:
NORTH J
DATE OF ORDER:
8 JULY 2011
WHERE MADE:
MELBOURNE

UPON THE APPLICANT BY HIS COUNSEL UNDERTAKING TO THE COURT:

  1. To disclaim any possessory lien in respect of bankrupt estate files and funds in trust held by him or under his control in respect of the administrations;
  2. To make available by 2 pm on Tuesday 12 July 2011, for collection by the Official Trustee all files and funds in respect of the administrations and otherwise cooperate with and assist the Official Trustee as reasonably required and at no cost to him, in assuming the conduct of the administrations; and
  3. To cease carrying out, consenting to or otherwise accepting appointment as a registered trustee under the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) (the Act) until such times as he has produced evidence in a form acceptable to the Inspector-General in Bankruptcy, a committee formed pursuant to Division 1 of Part VIII of the Act or to the Court demonstrating his practical and financial capacity adequately and properly to carry out his duties as a registered trustee.

THE COURT ORDERS CONSENT THAT:

  1. Pursuant to section 180 of the Act, the Court accepts the resignation of the Applicant from the office of trustee of each of the bankrupt estates listed in Annexure “A” hereto.

Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
The text of entered orders can be located using Federal Law Search on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION
VID 644 of 2011

IN THE MATTER OF MOHAMED ABDULRAHMAN AND OTHERS (AS PER ANNEXURE “A”)



PAUL ANTHONY PATTISON (AS TRUSTEE OF THE BANKRUPT ESTATES OF MOHAMED ABDULRAHMAN AND OTHERS (AS PER ANNEXURE “A”))
Applicant

JUDGE:
NORTH J
DATE:
8 JULY 2011
PLACE:
MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. Before the Court is an application by Paul Anthony Pattison under s 180 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) (the Act), for the Court to accept his resignation as trustee of the bankrupt estates listed in annexure A of these reasons.
  2. Mr Pattison is currently appointed as trustee of 272 bankrupt estates. The first hearing of the application occurred on 30 June 2011. Mr Pattison sought dispensation of the requirement under r 8.02(2)(b) of the Federal Court (Bankruptcy) Rules 2005 (Cth) for personal service of the application and supporting documents on all 272 bankrupt estates. The Court ordered that personal service be dispensed with, but that Mr Pattison serve a copy of his affidavit and a letter explaining the nature of his application and the date of the adjourned hearing by ordinary mail on the bankrupts. In an affidavit sworn on 8 July 2011, Mr Pattison explained that he had complied with that order and service was effected on each of the bankrupts by close of business on 1 July 2011.
  3. In support of his application for the Court to accept his resignation, Mr Pattison filed an affidavit sworn on 17 June 2011 giving his reasons for seeking the order. He explained that he has practised as a registered trustee in bankruptcy since 1986, and practised as a sole practitioner from October 1997, supported by a staff of up 43 employees who practised in both personal and corporate insolvency administrations. The staff involved in that business were employed by Pattison Consulting Pty Ltd (Pattison Consulting). Pattison Consulting also provided administrative services to Mr Pattison as an insolvency practitioner. The revenue flow from the practice suffered a downturn as a result of the advantageous financial circumstances in the last decade. As a result of pressure from creditors, Mr Pattison placed Pattison Consulting into voluntary liquidation on 22 April 2010. He also reduced his overheads by relinquishing premises in the CBD, shifting to offices in Box Hill, and reducing his staff numbers.
  4. Arising from the liquidation of Pattison Consulting, the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) commenced investigations and Mr Pattison voluntarily agreed to resign his corporate insolvency appointments. He gave an undertaking to the Court not to take any further appointments until further order or agreement with ASIC. These events affected Mr Pattison’s ability to continue his personal bankruptcy practice. He explains in his affidavit:
4.7 Since 7 March 2011 I have continued to conduct my remaining bankruptcy practice, as a sole practitioner and on minimal overheads. However, since I have now come to the view that I do not have adequate financial or staff resources now or in the foreseeable future to conduct a practice as trustee in bankruptcy to administer the number of administrations currently under my control as identified in Annexure “A” to the Application.

  1. In response to the notice of this application provided by Mr Pattison to the bankrupt estates, a number of the bankrupts appeared at the hearing today to oppose the application. Mr Dennis Maher argued that he recently commenced an application in this Court against Mr Pattison, and that he wished to pursue that application. He handed the Court a copy of the application in proceeding VID 733/2011. In that application, Mr Maher relies on s 30 and s 82 of the Act, and contends that several debts, which have apparently been regarded by Mr Pattison as provable in Mr Maher’s bankruptcy, are not provable. The application in effect seeks orders that the debts involved are not provable debts in the bankruptcy.
  2. The question raised by Mr Maher’s application does not depend on Mr Pattison’s continuance as trustee. If the Court accepts the resignation of Mr Pattison then a substitute trustee will assume the appointment. That trustee will then be in a position to assess the question raised by Mr Maher’s application. In oral submissions, Mr Maher said he wished to amend the application in order to commence proceedings against Mr Pattison personally. Mr Pattison does not seek a release from any liabilities incurred in the conduct of his office as trustee. Consequently, Mr Maher is at liberty to commence proceedings, as he may be so advised, whether Mr Pattison continues as a registered trustee, or not. It follows that the matters raised by Mr Maher are not justified objections to the order sought by Mr Pattison.
  3. Mr Kristoffer Crichton was the second opponent to the order who appeared at the hearing today. He opposed the order and sought to raise matters about the administration of his bankrupt estate before the Court. For example, Mr Crichton sought an order from the Court that the trustee produce the proofs of debt in his bankruptcy. He said that his bankruptcy came about as a result of criminal conduct. He said it came about because of a transaction involving a contract of sale which was fraudulent. He sought an order from the Court that the contract of sale be produced. He explained that his bankruptcy had so far been handled by two trustees and he argued that it was unreasonable that he should be put to the trouble of dealing with a third trustee. He also argued that Mr Pattison has knowledge of his bankruptcy and this was a reason he should not be permitted to resign.
  4. The Court took some trouble to explain to Mr Crichton that this hearing was not the occasion to conduct an inquiry into his bankruptcy. One can understand Mr Crichton’s frustrations. However, he has avenues under the Act to vindicate any rights which flow from those frustrations. Buried amongst the general concerns about the administration of his estate, the only argument which carried some weight was the argument that Mr Pattison has knowledge of the bankrupt estate, and that Mr Crichton desires to know more about the administration than he presently does. Against that argument, however, is the evidence of Mr Pattison that he is not in a commercial position to administer the estates. That consideration is so overwhelming in the circumstances that it renders Mr Crichton’s concern of little relevance.
  5. Further, Mr Bigmore QC, who appeared on behalf of Mr Pattison, said that Mr Pattison is prepared to provide an undertaking to the Court that he will make available within a short time the files and funds in his possession concerning the bankrupt estates, and assist the Official Trustee as reasonably required, and at no cost to him, in the transition from his resignation to the appointment of a new trustee. That undertaking provides sufficient answer to Mr Crichton’s concerns.
  6. The fact that the Inspector General consents to the application is also a matter of significance. Although the evidence of Mr Pattison’s commercial incapacity to continue as a trustee of the bankrupt estates presents an almost unarguable case in favour of the Court accepting his resignation, the Court is given some assurance in taking that course by the consent of the Inspector General to the order. The fact that the Inspector General consents to the order indicates to the Court that the official charged with the proper administration of the Act has an informed view that the course proposed is a proper course.
  7. The proposed order by consent also includes an undertaking by counsel for Mr Pattison to disclaim any possessory lien in respect of the bankrupt estate files and funds held in trust by Mr Pattison, or under his control in respect of the administrations, and an undertaking to cease to carry out, or consent to, or otherwise accept an appointment as a registered trustee until such time as he produces evidence in a form acceptable to the Inspector General to a committee formed pursuant to Div 1, Part VIII of the Act, or to the Court, demonstrating his practical and financial capacity to adequately and properly to carry out his duties as a registered trustee.
  8. These undertakings, together with Mr Pattison’s undertaking to provide the files and funds in his possession within in a short time, and assist the Official Trustee in the transition from his resignation, justify the orders sought.
I certify that the preceding twelve (12) numbered paragraphs are a true copy of the Reasons for Judgment herein of the Honourable Justice North.

Associate:


Dated: 8 August 2011

ANNEXURE “A”


Bankruptcy No Surname Christian Name Date of

Appointment


3742/05
ABDULRAHMAN
Mohamed
18-Oct-05
2765/10/9
ACAR
Nurcan
21-Jun-10
2061/08
AINALIS
Leo
8-May-08
3107/10/1
ALDUCCI
Liala
3-Sep-10
2539/08
ALVES
Joao Maria
5-Jun-08
1865/08
ANGELATOS
Sam
29-Apr-08
1393/08
ASTRINAKIS
Tony
1-Apr-08
1604/04
ATHANASIOU
John
20-May-04
583/02
BAKER
Jacoba
21-Feb-02
1644/10/4
BAKER
Layal
1-Apr-10
583/02
BAKER
Steven
21-Feb-02
4823/07
BALAAM
Warren John
30-Oct-07
867/8/5
BARBEAU
MAURICE
26-Feb-08
2814/10/4
BARKER
Clement Joseph
22-Jun-10
4625/1/7
BARNES
Noel H
22-Nov-01
2682/04
BARR
Neville
13-Aug-04
917/08
BATTEN
Matthew
28-Feb-08
3781/03
BENALLACK
Ian
6-Nov-03
4164/6/1
BENIC
Ivan
12-Oct-06
1563/04
BENTLEY
Malcolm John
18-May-04
2823/95
BERG
Eric (deceased)
14-Nov-95
2823/95
BERG
E & J
14-Nov-95
2823/95
BERG
Jeanne Martin
14-Nov-95
1568/92
BERRY
Wayne Desmond
28-May-92
3468/5/4
BEYER
Nicole Anne
27-Sep-05
3326/08
BLASCHAK
Andrew
23-Jul-08
3328/08
BLASCHAK
Karen Elizabeth
23-Jul-08
328/05
BODRIAGAN
Valery Bodriagan
3-Feb-05
1246/2007
BORTHWICK
Ross
20-Mar-07
VIC462/6/9
BOUNYAVIENG
Onchanh
2-Feb-06
4622/09
BRAIN
Debbie
15-Sep-09
1228/2005
BRAIN
Lloyd
12-Apr-05
3053/2008
BRITT
Noel H
3-Jul-08
4803/09
BROMLEY
Trent
24-Sep-09
3903/05
BROWN
Annette Alice
3-Nov-05
2224/2010
BUCMAN
Alexandar
31-Mar-11
1171/09
BUDDHIPALA
Kumudu Kumar
24-Apr-09
3872/02
BUNTING
Grantly Keith
7-Nov-02
1447/2006
BURGESS
Anthony Charles
5-Apr-06
4415/10
BURR
Gary
17-Aug-10
2429/2007
BURRIDGE
Kerry Wayne
31-May-07
3613/077/1
BUTTIGIEG
ADAM
19-Jan-11
518/2009
BUZZA
Todd Patrick
3-Feb-09
1219/09/8
CAGEORGIS
John
12-Mar-09
1136/05
CALLEIA
Paul Anthony
7-Apr-05
769/6/6
CALLEJA
David
23-Feb-06
4560/09/3
CAMM
Peter Robert
11-Sep-09
5131/08/3
CARRUTHERS
Fiona Joy
31-Oct-08
3352/04
CARUANA
Andrew
30-Sep-04
4717/08
CIVOF
Kosta
9-Oct-08
1478/08
CLARKE
Kathleen
3-Apr-08
2139/08
COBANOGLU
Mustafa
13-May-08
1850/09/9
COLLINS
Janelle
14-Apr-09
445/03
COLUSIMO
Justin
6-Feb-03
1829/04
CONDON
Shannon
8-Jun-04
1240/05
CORTEZ
John
14-Apr-05
1641/04
COSIC
Marko
25-May-04
1583/08
COULTHARD
Colin John
10-Apr-08
2497/06
COURTIDIS
Justin Anthony
20-Jun-06
4718/08
COX
Paul
9-Oct-08
2489/09
COXHILL
David R
21-May-09
3345/5/1
CRANWELL
Richard
20-Sep-05
4964/09/7
CRICHTON
Kristoffer
27-Jul-10
2717/09
CROZIER
John Lawrence Rex
24-Jun-09
2191/5
CUGIA
Julita Noble
21-Jun-05
532/6/9
CUNNINGHAM
David Allan
7-Feb-06
4198/07
CURTIS
Darren R.
18-Sep-07
434/07
DAKAK
Atilla
30-Jan-07
4525/06
DALLWITZ
Hilton
2-Nov-06
2922/07
DALTON
Rae
26-Jun-08
496/5/2
DARDAMANIS
George
15-Feb-05
VIC422/6/9
DAVIES
John Robert
31-Jan-06
422/6/9
DAVIES
Maree Denise
31-Jan-06
5210/07
DAWES
Christine Anne
22-Nov-07
2089/0/0
DE GONZA
Rocco
19-Jun-00
1717/03
DEACON
Bernard
13-May-03
1717/03
DEACON
Scott Andrew
13-May-03
2206/6/3
DELOSA
Con
30-May-06
2631/08
DIMANNO
Giuseppe
5-Jun-08
3644/09
DINAKIS
Paul
19-Jan-11
4258/09/1
DOKHT
Vahid Faghir
7-Dec-09
428/05
DONEV
Vase Victor
10-Feb-05
1164/06
D'ORTENZIO
Bruno
24-Jun-06
3292/06
D'SOUZA
Russell
17-Oct-06
2811/02
DUKANAC
Alexander
15-Aug-02
4/10/2770
EDDEY
Michael Anthony
21-Jun-10
3132/08/0
ELLEM
Warran Ronald
8-Jul-08
3841/91
ENG
William
17-Dec-91
2250/09/3
FALKINGHAM
Dale Reginald
14-Aug-09
4865/08
FANTONE
Daryl
16-Oct-08
3517/10/7
FARES
Michael
12-Aug-10
3516/10/6
FARES
John
12-Aug-10
1581/10/1
FAVA
GODWIN
1-Apr-10
3248/2007
FERIGHETTO
Antonio Isaac
24-Jul-07
882/9/5
FISTROVIC
Zoran Richard
19-Apr-10
3335/02
FLEURY
John Fredrick
24-Sep-02
1348/6/5
GALLO
Frank
30-Mar-06
6037/08
GANDER
Colleen Anne
23-Dec-08
1350/04
GARDAM
Michael Gavin
3-May-04
1220/04
GEDGE
Norman L
20-Apr-04
1326/08
GIBSON
Dallas
27-Mar-08
3099/10/5
GIGGINS
Erica Janelle
30-Jun-10
1508/10/2
GOSLING
Garry Lloyd
17-Jun-10
575/09
GRACE
William
5-Feb-09
1113/10/3
GRIFFIN
Kathleen Jayne
9-Mar-10
2237/08/9
GRIMM
Bradley John
31-Oct-08
6299/09/8
GUST
Christina
22-Dec-09
371/08/3
GUST
Paul Anthony
24-Nov-08
3914/08/2
HALEY
Mark Christopher
26-Aug-08
716/07
HAMILTON
Malcolm Alan
15-Feb-07
440/10
HARROD
Mark Adrian
30-Dec-10
2198/09
HARDWICK
Andrew
19-Jan-11
2463/09
HARDWICK
Helen
19-Jan-11
1500/09
HARTLEY
Francis Velia
26-Mar-09
2716/09
HENDRA
John Alan
24-Jun-09
2140/08
HOLDING
Anthony Laurence
13-May-08
2370/09/3
HOLMAN
Edyth Mary
25-Jun-09
2527/09/0
HOLMAN
William James
25-Jun-09
1586/02
HORTIN
Damien Christopher
9-May-02
1960/08
IGOE
Eric
1-May-08
3764/07
IJUIN
Toshi
23-Aug-07
685/07
ILHAN
Cengiz
13-Feb-07
4965/07
IOANNOU
Yiannakis (John)
5-Nov-07
1029 / 201
JACKSON
Gordon James
2766/10/0
JOSEVSKI
Zoranco
21-Jun-10
4047/00
KALLONAS
Christopher George
5-Dec-00
1414/2009
KAMBOURIS
Theo
23-Mar-09
853/09/2
KAPURANOVSKI
Anthony
19-Feb-09
685/07
KARITIANOS
Dill
13-Feb-07
2574/2007
KATUNOV
Alex
12-Jun-07
496/2009
KELLY
Warren
3-Feb-09
1274/08
KHEDER
Mounzer
20-Mar-08
4317/04
KIELY
Stephen John
21-Dec-04
QLD3591/09
KING
John Norman
8-Jul-09
QLD3591/09
KING
Brioney Anne
8-Jul-09
3510/05
KIRBY
Andrew Phillip
29-Sep-05
2582/08
KIRKHAM
David Robert
10-Jun-08
1075/10/5
KIRKHAM
John
9-Mar-10
596/11
KIRKHAM
Margaret Cheryl
15-Feb-11
2276/08
KONTOGIANNIS
Nikolos
22-May-08
4540/07
KOSTADINOSKI
Lupco Alex
31-Oct-07
803/08
KUMAR
Shalend
21-Feb-08
2282/08
KYRIACOU
Andrea
22-May-08
3301/5/7
LAITY
Ian
15-Sep-05
1566/09/5
LANE
Garry
31-Mar-09
3003/09/2
LANGTON
Bryan
18-Jun-09
3145/08/3
LAWRENCE
Michael W
8-Jul-08
2102/06
LEECH
Ian David
2-Nov-07
3349/00
LEMPRIERE
Thomas Charles
10-Apr-01
805/01
LEMPRIERE
Pauline Veronica
8-May-01
3066/10/0
LESLIE
William Joseph Nevill
9-Jul-10
3565/09/4
LI
Abbie
21-Jul-09
3233/03
LINTON
Kevin Douglas
25-Sep-03
3594/05/0
LOKVANCIC
Olga
6-Oct-05
563/04
LOSIC
Joe
24-Feb-04
259/6/6
LOWTHER
Janice
19-Jan-06
4859/07
MACH
Chieu Minh
30-Oct-07
349/2011
MACCIOCCA
Marco Paolo
1-Feb-11
4449/08
MADDEN
Ashley James
23-Sep-08
3834/08/2
MAHER
Dennis
15-Aug-08
3650/05/6
MAHONEY
Lee Michelle
11-Oct-05
3513/09/2
MALTER
Richard Lawrence
16-Jul-09
4383/01
MANI
Cemal
1-Nov-01
1290/02
MARCHETTI
Paul Stuart
17-Jun-02
1738/02
MARCHETTI
Stuart Paul
21-May-02
393 10/3
MARIOTIS
Jim
28-Jan-10
2709/06/6
MARKOVSKI
Tony
6-Jul-06
4241/07
MAROM
LEE
20-Sep-07
3298/10/8
MARQUARDT
Lee
22-Jul-10
3348/5/4
MASTROIANNI
Mario
20-Sep-05
2433/05
MATTHEWS
Kelly
12-Jul-05
2559/02
McFARLANE
William Scott
25-Jul-02
828/03
McGUSHIN
Michael
6-Mar-03
3455/5/1
MCKINNON
Donald Neil
26-Aug-05
3453/5/9
MCKINNON
Jeanette Beverly Dawn
26-Aug-05
5415/07
MCMILLAN
Jodi Anne
4-Dec-07
3408/10/8
MERRILL
James
6-Jul-10
2053/08
MICHAELS
John
8-May-08
444/08
MILLICHIP
Beverley Lee
31-Jan-08
1529/08
MIRCEVSKI
Alex
8-Apr-08
1792/08
MOORBY
Alex William
22-Apr-08
2135/07
MUCKENTHALER
Janos Joseph
15-May-07
3653/08
MUELLER
Joanne
12-Aug-08
5415/07
NICHOLLS
Gregory Alan
4-Dec-07
5415/07
NICHOLLS & MCMILLAN
J A
4-Dec-07
5179/07
NOVAK
Michael
20-Nov-07
1221/09
O'BRIEN
Carl Goerge
12-Mar-09
1081/10/1
OLIPHANT
William John Paul
9-Mar-10
3449/10/9
OLIVER
Kathlyn M
3-Aug-10
1961/10/5
OLSEN
Janet
24-Jun-10
445/03
OULIARIS
Christopher
6-Feb-03
4868/07
OWENS
Georgina Mariel
1-Nov-07
1656/09/5
PADAYACHEE
Shantal
2-Apr-09
317/05/3
PAPIGIOTIS
Chris
1-Feb-05
NSW6032/09
PARBERY
Steve
27-Jul-09
2362/09/1
PASCAL
Craig
14-May-09
1395/08
PATAKI
Frank
1-Apr-08
3749/05/5
PATON
Matthew David
18-Oct-05
1507/09
PATTERSON
Douglas
26-Mar-09
3943/06
PAUL
Robert
28-Sep-06
3943/06
PAUL
Susan Theresa
28-Sep-06
4340/07
PAULO
Perenise Tai Vai
27-Sep-07
1850/09/9
PEIRPOINT
Darryl
14-Apr-09
1458/2011
PENNICOTT
Gabrial
5-Apr-11
5308/09/7
PHILIPPOUSSIS
Nicholas Salvatore
16-Dec-09
2055/09/4
PRICE
Graham Kenlock
28-Apr-09
2767/10/1
PSATOPOLOUS
EFTHIMIOS
21-Jun-10
3282/09/1
RAEK
Nezar
2-Jul-09
2396/05
RAMOS
Rodrigo Javier
7-Jul-05
1321/08
RHOOK
Anthony
27-Mar-08
2837/2007
ROLANDO
Anthony
28-Jun-07
4365/09/4
ROSE
Michael
1-Sep-09
3004/03
ROSS-CROSSLEY
Gareth Roy
4-Sep-03
573/09
RULE
Tracey Leanne
5-Feb-09
1265/10/5
SALUNI
SAMIU
18-Mar-10
3024/09/3
SAMI
Roshni
18-Jun-09
3599/09
SAMI
Bob
23-Jul-09
2456/05
SAWTELL
Craig John
14-Jul-05
1969/09/8
SER
Henry
21-Apr-09
2504/03
SHORT
Geoffrey
22-Jul-03
523/2009/2
SIME
Christopher James
3-Feb-09
5209/10
SIMMONS
Nova
9-Dec-10
1923/03
SINCLAIR
Kenneth John
29-May-03
1398/08
SINGH
Virendra
1-Apr-08
5340/07
SKEOCH
Kerry Lee
29-Nov-07
5340/07
SKEOCH
Ian Alan
29-Nov-07
1057/09/6
SLOMCZEWSKI
Mark
3-Mar-09
945/07
SNOWDEN
Stephen George
28-Feb-07
1392/08
SOURANI
Diari
1-Apr-08
5157/08
SPAIN
Lee Adrian
3-Nov-08
1985/01
SPINA
Moreno
10-May-01
3761/07
STEPHANOU
Manny
23-Aug-07
4446/07
STEPHENS
Kenneth Lyle
4-Oct-07
3534/03
STEVENS
Brenda Florence
16-Oct-03
4322/5/8
STOLK
Jason Paul
1-Dec-05
878/05
STORY
Margaret Mary
17-Mar-05
3447/08
STRANGIO
Bruno
28-Jul-08
2293/5/9
STUBER
John
30-Jun-05
1020/96
SUTHERLAND
Wilma Jean
16-Apr-96
2283/08
SUMMERS
Fiona Gaye
22-May-08
5553/2008
TABAKOVIC
Ivan
24-Nov-08
4883/09/2
TAIKATO
Vern
29-Sep-09
2768/04
TATNELL
Graham Edward
19-Aug-04
4996/09
TAUTATAINA
Taliauli
6-Oct-09
4887/06
TAYLOR
Christine Antoinette
23-Nov-06
4014/10
TAYLOR
Eileen
14-Sep-10
4849/08
TETRADIS
George
14-Oct-08
4448/07
THOMSON
Rodney David
4-Oct-07
1771/6/8
TILLEY
Justin
2-May-06
3706/02/9
TO
Phong
15-Oct-02
3073/2007
TRIBE
Keith John
10-Jul-07
2597/10/7
TRIGGS
Kylie Maria
3-Jun-10
3559/09/8
TSONIS
Steve
21-Jul-09
2242/04
UGUZ
Aydin
8-Jul-04
4127/07
VAN ALPHEN
Didi, Jennifer
13-Sep-07
2307/99
VAUGHAN
Annemarie
21-Jul-99
779/6/6
VENTRESCA
Anthony Joseph
23-Feb-06
1663/07
VIOLA
Tony Orazio
12-Apr-07
593/05
VON DIEBITSCH
Peter
22-Feb-05
984/08
VONA
Giovanni
4-Mar-08
1982/09/5
WADE
Raymond Joseph
29-Jul-09
1984/09/7
WADE
Karolee Mary
29-Jul-09
2365/4
WALKER
John
20-Jul-04
4156/06
WATSON
Lawrence Robert Bruce
12-Oct-06
1478/08
WEIR
Adam Patrick
3-Apr-08
3777/6/4
WHITBY
Judith Wendy
19-Sep-06
2543/09/6
WHITELAW
Sherryl Ann
26-May-09
4502/07
WILLIAMS
Allan
9-Oct-07
3163/10/3
WOWK
Paul
15-Jul-10
1159/10/3
WRIGHT
Elle Victoria
13-Jul-10
2978/05/4
YU
Qun Xiong (Kenny)
17-Aug-05
3512/09
YUDELMAN
Alan
16-Jul-09
2811/05/7
ZDELAR
Stjepan Matija
11-Aug-05


AustLII: Copyright Policy | Disclaimers | Privacy Policy | Feedback
URL: http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/cases/cth/FCA/2011/899.html