[Home] [Databases] [WorldLII] [Search] [Feedback]

Federal Court of Australia

You are here: AustLII >> Databases >> Federal Court of Australia >> 2010 >> [2010] FCA 71

[Database Search] [Name Search] [Recent Decisions] [Noteup] [Download] [Help]

United Group Resources Pty Ltd ABN 17 114 888 201 v Calabro (No 2) [2010] FCA 71 (12 February 2010)

Last Updated: 15 February 2010

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

United Group Resources Pty Ltd ABN 17 114 888 201 v Calabro (No 2) [2010] FCA 71

Citation:	United Group Resources Pty Ltd ABN 17 114 888 201 v Calabro (No 2) [2010] FCA 71

Parties:	UNITED GROUP RESOURCES PTY LTD ABN 17 114 888 201, AGC INDUSTRIES PTY LTD ABN 57 079 939 898, MODERN ACCESS SERVICES PTY LTD ABN 87 129 312 590, DOWNER EDI ENGINEERING POWER PTY LTD ABN 53 000 983 700, MONADELPHOUS ENGINEERING ASSOCIATES PTY LTD ABN 52 008 861 836, CBI CONSTRUCTORS PTY LTD ABN 90 000 612 411, DECMIL AUSTRALIA PTY LTD ABN 58 116 776 991, FREO GROUP LIMITED ABN 64 009 325 124, MAMMOET AUSTRALIA PTY LTD ABN 77 075 483 644, PCH GROUP LTD ABN 41 009 120 021, RCR CONSTRUCTION & MAINTENANCE PTY LTD ABN 97 063 053 814, RCR POSITRON PTY LTD ABN 38 106 084 879 and JOHN HOLLAND PTY LTD ABN 11 004 282 268 v BRAEDEN CALABRO AND OTHERS LISTED IN THE RESPONDENTS' SCHEDULE A AS AMENDED and THE AUSTRALIAN BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSIONER

File number:	WAD 14 of 2010

Judge:	MCKERRACHER J

Date of judgment:	12 February 2010

Catchwords:	INDUSTRIAL LAW - interim injunction – extension of interim injunction - jurisdiction to grant injunction - unlawful industrial action - relevant considerations in exercising discretion – whether injunction until trial or at all should be granted when unlawful conduct has ceased and evidence as to probable imminent recurrence is very limited – relevance of previous history – no notice to respondents of intention to seek interlocutory injunction until trial – strong primary case as to historical breaches and very strong balance of convenience

Legislation:	Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005 (Cth) ss 37, 38, 39, 49(3) Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) Federal Court Rules O 7 r 9

Cases cited:	Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2009] FCA 1092 CBI Construction Pty Ltd v Abbott (2008) 177 IR 134 ICI Australia Operations Pty Ltd v Trade Practices Commission [1992] FCA 474; (1992) 38 FCR 248 John Holland Pty Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (2005) 144 IR 418 Kestrel Coal Pty Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2001] 1 Qd R 634 Leighton Contractors Pty Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (2006) 149 IR 299 Leighton Contractors Pty Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (2006) 149 IR 306 Leighton Contractors Pty Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (2006) 154 IR 228 Patrick Stevedores Operations Pty Ltd v Maritime Union of Australia (1998) 82 IR 87 United Group Infrastructure Pty Ltd v Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union (2005) 148 IR 399 United Group Resources Pty Ltd ABN 17 114 888 201 v Calabro [2010] FCA 22

Date of hearing:		5 February 2010

Place:		Perth

Division:		FAIR WORK DIVISION

Category:		Catchwords

Number of paragraphs:		31

Counsel for the Applicants:		K de Kerloy with K Reid

Solicitor for the Applicants:		Freehills

No appearance for the Respondents.

Solicitor for the Intervener:		B Mueller

Counsel for the Intervener:		Clayton Utz

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
FAIR WORK DIVISION	WAD 14 of 2010

BETWEEN:	UNITED GROUP RESOURCES PTY LTD ABN 17 114 888 201 First Applicant AGC INDUSTRIES PTY LTD ABN 57 079 939 898 Second Applicant MODERN ACCESS SERVICES PTY LTD ABN 87 129 312 590 Third Applicant DOWNER EDI ENGINEERING POWER PTY LTD ABN 53 000 983 700 Fourth Applicant MONADELPHOUS ENGINEERING ASSOCIATES PTY LTD ABN 52 008 861 836 Fifth Applicant CBI CONSTRUCTORS PTY LTD ABN 90 000 612 411 Sixth Applicant DECMIL AUSTRALIA PTY LTD ABN 58 116 776 991 Seventh Applicant FREO GROUP LIMITED ABN 64 009 325 124 Eighth Applicant MAMMOET AUSTRALIA PTY LTD ABN 77 075 483 644 Ninth Applicant PCH GROUP LTD ABN 41 009 120 021 Tenth Applicant RCR CONSTRUCTION & MAINTENANCE PTY LTD ABN 97 063 053 814 Eleventh Applicant RCR POSITRON PTY LTD ABN 38 106 084 879 Twelfth Applicant JOHN HOLLAND PTY LTD ABN 11 004 282 268 Thirteenth Applicant
AND:	BRAEDEN CALABRO AND OTHERS LISTED IN THE RESPONDENTS' SCHEDULE A AS AMENDED Respondents
AND:	THE AUSTRALIAN BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSIONER Intervener

JUDGE:	MCKERRACHER J
DATE OF ORDER:	5 FEBRUARY 2010
WHERE MADE:	PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

Upon the applicants having given the usual undertaking as to damages, until 5.00 pm on 18 February 2010 or further order, pursuant to s 39 and/or s 49(1)(c) of the Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005 (Cth) each respondent is restrained from:

(a) engaging in or being a party to or in any way associated with or otherwise involved in any of the following actions in relation to building work on the Pluto LNG Project at Burrup Peninsula (Project):

(i) failing or refusing to attend work on the Project or failing or refusing to accept or perform work on the Project at all;

(ii) performing work on the Project otherwise than in accordance with the terms of his employment contract;

(iii) performing work on the Project in a manner different from that in which it is customarily performed, or adopting any practice in relation to work on the project, the result of which is a restriction or limitation on, or a delay in, the performance of that work;

except where such actions:

(i) are authorised or agreed to by the respondent’s employer; or

(ii) are based upon the respondent’s reasonable concern about an imminent risk to the respondent’s health or safety and the respondent has not unreasonably failed to comply with the directions of the respondent’s employer to perform other available work, whether at the same or another workplace, that was safe and appropriate for the respondent to perform;

(b) interfering with or in any way disrupting the performance of work on the Project by any of the following means:

(i) imposing, maintaining or aiding, abetting, encouraging, directing, procuring, inducing, advising or otherwise being involved in any bans, limitations, restrictions or delays on the performance of work or the acceptance of work by any of the applicants’ other employees to be performed under their terms of employment or in a manner which work is customarily performed with the applicants; and

(ii) imposing, maintaining or aiding, abetting, encouraging, directing, procuring, inducing, advising or otherwise being involved in the taking of days off by any of the applicants’ other employees otherwise than in accordance with rosters specified by the industrial instruments and employment contracts regulating their employment with the applicants.

Any further application for an interlocutory injunction be listed for hearing at 10.00 am on Thursday 18 February 2010 together with a directions hearing.
Any person affected by the restraints imposed by the injunctive relief has liberty to apply on 48 hours written or electronic notice to the applicants or the Australian Building and Construction Commission.
Costs be reserved.
Without limitation as to other means of service, it will be sufficient service of this Order upon each of the respondents if a copy of this Order is:

(a) posted to each respondent at their known address;

(b) placed on the notice board(s) usually used for the purpose of communicating with the respondents at the workplace; and

(c) provided by email or fax to the representatives of the Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (CFMEU), the Australian Manufacturing Workers Union (AMWU) and the Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union (CEPU) who have been attending the workplace.

Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
The text of entered orders can be located using Federal Law Search on the Court’s website.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
FAIR WORK DIVISION	WAD 14 of 2010

BETWEEN:	UNITED GROUP RESOURCES PTY LTD ABN 17 114 888 201 First Applicant AGC INDUSTRIES PTY LTD ABN 57 079 939 898 Second Applicant MODERN ACCESS SERVICES PTY LTD ABN 87 129 312 590 Third Applicant DOWNER EDI ENGINEERING POWER PTY LTD ABN 53 000 983 700 Fourth Applicant MONADELPHOUS ENGINEERING ASSOCIATES PTY LTD ABN 52 008 861 836 Fifth Applicant CBI CONSTRUCTORS PTY LTD ABN 90 000 612 411 Sixth Applicant DECMIL AUSTRALIA PTY LTD ABN 58 116 776 991 Seventh Applicant FREO GROUP LIMITED ABN 64 009 325 124 Eighth Applicant MAMMOET AUSTRALIA PTY LTD ABN 77 075 483 644 Ninth Applicant PCH GROUP LTD ABN 41 009 120 021 Tenth Applicant RCR CONSTRUCTION & MAINTENANCE PTY LTD ABN 97 063 053 814 Eleventh Applicant RCR POSITRON PTY LTD ABN 38 106 084 879 Twelfth Applicant JOHN HOLLAND PTY LTD ABN 11 004 282 268 Thirteenth Applicant
AND:	BRAEDEN CALABRO AND OTHERS LISTED IN THE RESPONDENTS' SCHEDULE A AS AMENDED Respondents
AND:	THE AUSTRALIAN BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSIONER Intervener

JUDGE:	MCKERRACHER J
DATE:	12 FEBRUARY 2010
PLACE:	PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

On 5 February 2010, I made the orders published with these reasons. Having given short oral reasons, I indicated that I would produce more detailed written reasons. I now do so.

INTRODUCTION

On 27 January 2010, in United Group Resources Pty Ltd ABN 17 114 888 201 v Calabro [2010] FCA 22 (United Group No 1), an ex parte interim injunction for 9 days in terms similar to those published with these reasons was ordered. The applicants have sought an interlocutory injunction extending those orders until trial. I was not prepared to extend the orders until trial but did grant an extension of the orders for 13 days until 18 February 2010.
The applicants served the original interim injunction order against the many respondents between 29 and 31 January 2010. Most of the respondents returned to work following service of that order.
There are, as indicated in United Group No 1, in excess of 1500 respondents. No affidavits have been filed by any of the respondents. One of the main concerns in relation to granting an interlocutory injunction until trial was that none of the respondents has been given express notice of the intention to apply for such an interlocutory injunction today. In normal circumstances, but for the considerations which appear elsewhere in these reasons, on that basis alone I would have been disinclined to grant further relief, let alone an interlocutory injunction until trial. However, given the history disclosed on the evidence, I was persuaded that limited further orders should be made.
As reflected in United Group No 1, I am satisfied on the evidence that there is an arguable case that the respondents have engaged in ‘unlawful industrial action’ (as defined there and below) at the Pluto LNG Project at the Burrup Peninsula (the Project) in contravention of the Woodside Pluto LNG Project 2009 No. 2 order of Fair Work Australia dated 23 January 2010 and in breach of the Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005 (Cth) (BCII Act) and the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth).

BACKGROUND

The evidence relied upon by the applicants, at least at a prima facie level, does establish that:
- the applicants are building contractors engaged to carry out the construction of the Project, currently the biggest construction project in the North West of Western Australia;
- the respondents are building workers employed by the applicants in connection with the construction of the Project;
- over 1600 respondents were on strike between 22 January 2010 until 30 January 2010 in protest over changes to their accommodation arrangements;
- their action disrupted the performance of the work on the Project and caused significant direct and immediate financial loss to the applicants and the owner¸ Woodside Burrup Pty Ltd, presently estimated to be around $500,000 per day of the strike. Other losses are also likely to be suffered in due course arising from the delays to the Project caused by the strike;
- on 23 January 2010, orders were made by Commissioner Cloghan of Fair Work Australia for employees of the applicants (other than the thirteenth applicant) who were union members to return to work, such orders to remain in force until 28 February 2010; and
- the order of Commissioner Cloghan was not complied with as the respondents continued their unlawful strike until 30 January 2010;
There is additional but not unequivocal evidence that:
- on 28 and 29 January 2010, some of the respondents organised picket lines on the access road to the Project site. The picket lines caused significant disruption, with vehicles banked back approximately 3 – 4 kilometres at certain times during the day;
- media reports quoting senior union representatives indicate that there was a possibility of further industrial action if the respondents’ demands are not met; and
- no undertakings have been given by the respondents or their representatives that further unlawful industrial action will not be taken.

JURISDICTION

The Court has jurisdiction under s 39 and s 49 of the BCII Act to grant injunctive relief to prevent the respondents from engaging in ‘unlawful industrial action’. That action is defined in s 37 of the BCII Act as being building industrial action that is:

(a) industrially motivated;
(b) constitutionally connected; and
(c) not ‘excluded’.

Relevantly, s 39 and s 49 BCII Act respectively provide as follows:

39 Injunction against unlawful industrial action

(1) If, on application by the ABC Commissioner or any other person, an appropriate court is satisfied that unlawful industrial action is:

(a) occurring; or
(b) threatened, impending or probable;
then the court may grant an injunction in such terms as the court considers appropriate.

(2) If, in the opinion of the court it is desirable to do so, the court may grant an interim injunction pending determination of an application under subsection (1).

(3) The power of the court to grant an injunction restraining a person (the defendant) from engaging in conduct may be exercised:

(a) whether or not it appears to the court that the defendant intends to engage again, or to continue to engage, in conduct of that kind; and
(b) whether or not the defendant has previously engaged in conduct of that kind; and
(c) whether or not there is an imminent danger of substantial damage to any person if the defendant engages in conduct of that kind.

(4) In this section

appropriate court means the Federal Court, the Federal Magistrates Court, a Supreme Court of a State or Territory or a District Court, or County Court, of a State.

49 Penalties etc. for contravention of civil penalty provision

(1) An appropriate court, on application by an eligible person, may make one or more of the following orders in relation to a person (the defendant) who has contravened a civil penalty provision:

(a) an order imposing a pecuniary penalty on the defendant;
(b) an order requiring the defendant to pay a specified amount to another person as compensation for damage suffered by the other person as a result of the contravention;
(c) any other order that the court considers appropriate.

...
(3) The orders that may be made under paragraph (1)(c) include:

(a) injunctions (including interim injunctions); and
(b) any other orders that the court considers necessary to stop the conduct or remedy its effects, including orders for the sequestration of assets.

(4) If the contravention is a contravention of section 38, then the power of the court to grant an injunction restraining a person (the defendant) from engaging in conduct may be exercised:

(a) whether or not it appears to the court that the defendant intends to engage again, or to continue to engage, in conduct of that kind; and
(b) whether or not the defendant has previously engaged in conduct of that kind; and
(c) whether or not there is an imminent danger of substantial damage to any person if the defendant engages in conduct of that kind.

(5) A pecuniary penalty is payable to the Commonwealth, or to some other person if the court so directs. It may be recovered as a debt.

(6) Each of the following is an eligible person for the purposes of this section:

(a) the ABC Commissioner;
(b) an ABC Inspector;
(c) a person affected by the contravention;
(d) a person prescribed by the regulations for the purposes of this paragraph.

...

Section 38 of the BCII Act provides that a person must not engage in unlawful industrial action. As previously determined in United Group No 1, I am satisfied for present purposes that there is an arguable case that the industrial action is unlawful. It is clear from s 49(3) of the BCII Act, that the Court may grant an interlocutory injunction in relation to the respondents who have contravened civil penalty provisions of which s 38 of the BCII Act is one.

SHOULD RELIEF BE GRANTED WHEN RESPONDENTS HAVE RETURNED TO WORK, CEASING THEIR UNLAWFUL INDUSTRIAL ACTION?

As previously observed in United Group No 1, s 49(3) of the BCII Act confers power to grant an interlocutory injunction without reaching a final decision that a contravention has occurred: Leighton Contractors Pty Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (2006) 149 IR 299 (at [7], [8]); Leighton Contractors Pty Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (2006) 149 IR 306 (at [52]). As with s 39(3), s 49(4) of the BCII Act provides, in effect, that if the contravention is a contravention of s 38, then the power of the Court to grant an injunction restraining conduct may be exercised whether or not it appears to the Court that the defendant intends to engage in again or to continue to engage in conduct of the kind prohibited by s 38. The power to grant an injunction including an interlocutory injunction under s 49 of the BCII Act is additional to the Court’s power under s 39 of the BCII Act. It does not require the Court to be satisfied that unlawful industrial action is occurring or is threatened, impending or probable. It is open to the Court under s 49 of the BCII Act to make and order that ‘it considers appropriate’.
The power to grant an interim injunction under s 49(3) of the BCII Act will be exercised having regard to the principles applied by a court of equity, nevertheless noting that the main object of the BCII Act is a relevant consideration: United Group Infrastructure Pty Ltd v Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union (2005) 148 IR 399 (at [23]-[25]). As previously observed in United Group No 1, the main object of the BCII Act is set out in s 3. Section 3(1) provides:

3 Main object of Act

(1) The main object of this Act is to provide an improved workplace relations framework for building work to ensure that building work is carried out fairly, efficiently and productively for the benefit of all building industry participants and for the benefit of the Australian economy as a whole.

Subsection (2) spells out that the main object is to be achieved by the following means amongst others:
- promoting respect for the rule of law;
- ensuring respect for the rights of building industry participants;
- ensuring that building industry participants are accountable for their unlawful conduct.
As observed in United Group No 1, there is also an arguable case at present that in addition to the conduct being unlawful by virtue of s 38 of the BCII Act, the industrial action in which the respondents have engaged to date contravenes s 417(1) and s 421 of the Fair Work Act. Importantly, it also contravenes a breach of the order of Commissioner Cloghan of Fair Work Australia of 23 January 2010.
The dialogue directly between the applicants and the respondents on this industrial issue appears to be relatively limited. There does not appear to have been any undertaking given to the applicants that further unlawful industrial action will not occur. However, there is evidence that dialogue has been ensuing between the Unions of which the respondents are members (on the one hand) and (on the other), Foster Wheeler WorleyParsons, which supervises the Project. This has occurred with the helpful assistance of the Hon Deputy President BP McCarthy of Fair Work Australia.
I have had concerns as to the appropriateness of continuing an injunction in circumstances where the respondents have not been given specific notice of the intention to apply for an interlocutory injunction. That said, I do note counsel for the applicants’ assurance that the respective unions representing the various workers covered in the schedule of respondents were notified of the intention to bring the application and have not notified the Court or the applicants of any wish to be heard or heard on behalf of the respondents.
Nevertheless, express notification to the respondents of the intention to apply for an interlocutory injunction is the more preferable course before seeking or granting that relief without notice.
Although there is a strong arguable case that contraventions have occurred in the past, the strength of the case as to ‘probable’ future contraventions is, nevertheless, not great as the majority of the respondents have returned to work. While there is evidence that the dispute is not resolved, the evidence that the respondents will resume unlawful industrial action between now and 18 February 2010 is very limited.
Several previous decisions have addressed the question of whether or not the fact that unlawful conduct has ceased should in itself be sufficient to decline the grant of an injunction sought. It has been determined that the fact the unlawful industrial action has ceased is not of itself a reason not to grant an injunction. Examples of such decisions include Leighton Contractors Pty Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (2006) 154 IR 228; John Holland Pty Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (2005) 144 IR 418; United Group Infrastructure; CBI Construction Pty Ltd v Abbott (2008) 177 IR 134; and Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2009] FCA 1092.
Specifically in John Holland, Le Miere J held at [77]:

[77] The degree of probability of future injury is not an absolute standard. What is to be aimed at is justice between the parties, having regard to all the relevant circumstances: Hooper v Rogers at 50 per Russell LJ followed by the Full Federal Court in Magic Menu Systems Pty Ltd v AFA Facilitation Pty Ltd at 269-270. Provided that there is a real risk of wrongful conduct which would cause injury which is more than trivial, there may be no good reason to refuse quia timet relief: CGM Investments Pty Ltd v Chelliah (No 2) [2003] FCA 305 at [4] per Finkelstein J.

Likewise, also Nicholson J in United Group Infrastructure (at 44), held as follows:

[44] The balance of convenience then requires consideration. I accept the submission that the strength of the case of the arguability of the serious issues to be tried does weigh to some degree in the balance of convenience. I am influenced by the reference to Kestrel Coal Pty Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2001] 1 Qd R 634 at [22]-[30] particularly at [22], [28] and [30] which I will not repeat here.

In that decision cited by Nicholson J (Kestrel Coal Pty Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2001] 1 Qd R 634), Chesterman J said (at [30]):

[30] In this context it is relevant that the defendants maintained their unlawful obstruction for several weeks and only permitted free access after the interlocutory injunction was ordered. This is not a case of idle threats. The defendants have in the past acted unlawfully in violation of the plaintiffs' rights. This factor makes the case different from those in which an injunction is sought because of conduct which is only apprehended. The principles applicable to quia timet injunctions are not entirely applicable. The fact that unlawful conduct has occurred makes the court more disposed towards ordering relief. See Dean and Chapter of Chester v. Smelting Corporation Limited (1901) 85 LT 67 at 69 and Attorney General v. Beck [1980] 2 NSWLR 77 at 94-95.

The Full Court has also held that the question of repetition of unlawful conduct is relevant to the exercise of discretion, but relevance is set in the particular context of public interest injunctions as distinct from those related only to private proprietary interests: ICI Australia Operations Pty Ltd v Trade Practices Commission [1992] FCA 474; (1992) 38 FCR 248 at 256-257 per Lockhart J; at 267 per Gummow J and 268 per French J.

BALANCE OF CONVENIENCE

The balance of convenience strongly favours short term relief being extended. On the basis of the evidence at present, the effect on the applicants and the owners of the Project, Woodside Burrup Pty Ltd (Woodside), of further industrial action is most significant with an estimated direct cost alone exceeding $500,000 a day.
Additionally, there are potential consequences of industrial action such as damage to the reputation of the applicants and liquidated damages for delay. Woodside, in turn, would, if the delay continued, face potential losses arising from loss of revenue due to production delay. These considerations, extending as they do, to third parties, are nevertheless relevant: Patrick Stevedores Operations Pty Ltd v Maritime Union of Australia (1998) 82 IR 87.
The prospect of the respondents being able to meet an award in damages for such loss is unrealistic.
Moreover, the proper formulation of the test concerning the adequacy of damages is not whether they are an adequate remedy but whether it is ‘just in all the circumstances’ that the applicants should be ‘confined to a remedy in damages’: CBI Construction Pty Ltd v Abbott per Gilmour J (at [70]).
Underlying this dispute is said to be the issue concerning ‘motelling’ discussed in United Group No 1. There is evidence that some or all respondents who fly in, fly out to their work site, oppose a circumstance in which they are required to return to different temporary accommodation from that occupied on the previous work interval. While it might be thought that some practical measure could be adopted to address concerns arising from this complaint, the prospect of ‘motelling’ for a short term appears to be the only possible adverse consequence of restraining the respondents from engaging in further unlawful industrial action. On the other hand, they will at least, by returning to and remaining at work, be paid in accordance with Workplace Agreements.
For those reasons, as the balance of convenience strongly favours the orders being extended for a finite period, with liberty to apply being granted, I made orders for a brief period of time. These will preserve the status quo.

SERVICE

For service under 0 7 of the Federal Courts Rules, the respondents’ proper addresses are their home addresses rather than their addresses at the work site. However they travel from their home addresses to the work site which they occupy while employed at the site. The injunction primarily concerns their conduct at the work site. Wide publicity has surrounded this dispute including the making or these and previous orders. The Unions of which the respondents are members are and will be well aware of these and the previous orders in United Group No 1. In accordance with the power in O 7 r 9 of the Federal Court Rules I have made provision for substituted service of the orders that are made below, as the circumstances of the case require prompt service and personal service is impractical.
The orders I make are as follows:
1. Upon the applicants having given the usual undertaking as to damages, until 5.00 pm on 18 February 2010 or further order, pursuant to s 39 and/or s 49(1)(c) of the Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005 (Cth) each respondent is restrained from:

(i) failing or refusing to attend work on the Project or failing or refusing to accept or perform work on the Project at all;

(ii) performing work on the Project otherwise than in accordance with the terms of his employment contract;

except where such actions:

(i) are authorised or agreed to by the respondent’s employer; or

(b) interfering with or in any way disrupting the performance of work on the Project by any of the following means:

Any further application for an interlocutory injunction be listed for hearing at 10.00 am on Thursday 18 February 2010 together with a directions hearing.
Any person affected by the restraints imposed by the injunctive relief has liberty to apply on 48 hours written or electronic notice to the applicants or the Australian Building and Construction Commission.
Costs be reserved.
Without limitation as to other means of service, it will be sufficient service of this Order upon each of the respondents if a copy of this Order is:

(a) posted to each respondent at their known address;

(b) placed on the notice board(s) usually used for the purpose of communicating with the respondents at the workplace; and

I certify that the preceding thirty-one (31) numbered paragraphs are a true copy of the Reasons for Judgment herein of the Honourable Justice McKerracher.

Associate:

Dated: 12 February 2010

RESPONDENTS’ SCHEDULE A

Decmil Australia Pty Ltd

1 Calabro Braeden

2 Pearce Symeon

3 Lee Samuel

4 Johansson Michael

5 Connor John

6 Roberts Mitch

7 McCarty Grant

8 Grigarius Travis

9 Webb John

10 Kendall Simon

11 Scahill Adam

12 Watkins Lee

13 Gilmour Sam

14 Hales Rory

15 Brenton Michael

16 Henaway Caleb

17 Carman Steve

18 Hosking Peter

19 Day Paul

20 Peek Carl

21 Kohler Bradley

22 Smith Shannon

23 Clements Andrew

AGC Industries Pty Ltd

24 AINSWORTH Michael

25 ALWAYS Peter

26 ARKEVELD Dirk

27 BAKBAK Bekir

28 BARCHAM Stephen

29 BARKER Georffrey

30 BARTON Richard

31 BARWISE Richard

32 BEILKEN Grant

33 BERMINGHAM Simon

34 BENKIRANE Abdellilah

35 BIGLIN Scott

36 BLACKBOURNE Eden

37 BLOOR Graeme

38 BODY Ross

39 BOGOEVSKI Tom

40 BOWERS Gerard

41 BRIAGAS Genaro

42 BRITCHER Colin

43 BROWN John

44 BROWN Mark

45 BROWN Matthew

46 BROWN Thomas

47 BROWNE Keith

48 BRUCE Robert

49 BUNNER Colin

50 BUNYAN Paul

51 BURGER David

52 BURGESS Derek

53 BURNS James

54 BYERS Shannon

55 CALLAGHAN Stephen

56 CAMPBELL Bevan

57 CAMPION John

58 CARANDANG Adrian

59 CARDOSO Joaquim

60 CARR William

61 CASAS Ramon

62 CASSIDY Chris

63 CATTLE Leslie

64 CHARDON Anthony

65 CHO Han Jeong

66 CHO Myoung Ho

67 CLAY Luke

68 CLAYBURN Richard

69 CLIFTON Dane

70 COLEMAN Allen

71 COLEY Keith

72 COMIA Irineo

73 COOK Geoffrey

74 COSMOS Maria

75 CREAM Kevin

76 CREASEY Grant

77 DANIELL Jared

78 DAVIS Faisal

79 DELLAGOSTINO Ray

80 DOLAR Angel

81 DOWDLE Greg

82 DOWNES Joshua

83 DUDA Brendon

84 ELLIOT Trevor

85 ELLIS Brendon

86 ELLIS Gavin

87 FABER Andrew

88 FINLAYSON Dean

89 FOLEY David

90 FRANCIS Steven

91 FRASER David

92 GARVIE Sean

93 GAZEY Liam

94 GEOGHEGAN Aaron

95 GIBBONS Jean

96 GIBBS Wayne

97 GODDEN Toby

98 GREENLAND Rewi

99 GREHAN Paul

100 HALLAM Neil

101 HANN Troy

102 HANSFORD Gordon

103 HARDINGHAM Victor

104 HARRIS Aiden

105 HARRIS Jack

106 HARRIS Paul

107 HEBBARD Quinton

108 HILL Rodney

109 HILLIER Dion

110 HOPA Boyd

111 HOWELL Dylan

112 HOY Dion

113 HUBBERT Zeke

114 JACK John

115 JAENSCH Corey

116 JAHN Brad

117 JEFFERIES Brad

118 JENKINS Mark

119 JONES Steven

120 JOSEPHS Anthony

121 JOVANOVIC George

122 KAMPMAN Michael

123 KERMODE William

124 KHOO Meow-Ling

125 KIM Hyong Joo

126 KIM Jae Uk

127 KIM Keumyul

128 KIM Tae Shir

129 KNOWLER Steven

130 KOLAR Slavko

131 KYUNG Kyuyel

132 LEDGER Todd

133 LEE Anthony

134 LEE Chongil

135 LEE Hyungkil

136 LEE Kyuyil

137 LOVE Ray

138 LUCKMAN Graham

139 LYNCH Brian

140 MACFARLAN Chris

141 MACKENZIE Alex

142 MAIN Craig

143 MAMUDI Mudzait

144 MARQUES Augusto

145 MARSDEN Warren

146 MARSHALL Roy

147 MARTIN Kean

148 MATIC Mirko

149 MATTHEWS Michael

150 MAXWELL Matthew

151 McBRIDE Neil

152 McCONNELL Terry

153 McDERMOTT Dermott

154 MCLEAN Graham

155 McMILLAN Ian

156 MITCHELL-NGAWAKA Bruno

157 MOON Lee

158 MOREIRA Manuel

159 MORTI Rosita

160 MULLIGAN Barrie

161 NA Myoung Ho

162 PAEHUA Charles

163 PAKU Albert

164 PALLIER Matthew

165 PALLIER Stephen

166 PAMVOUXOGOLOU Benjamin

167 PELOSI Steven

168 PEPPER Shane

169 PES James

170 PES Leslie

171 PIVA Bernard

172 POTTS Paul

173 POUYE Paul

174 PRATLEY Steven

175 PUKE Taare

176 QUINTO Arturo

177 RAMADANI Berat

178 RAO Keith

179 RAVEN Grant

180 RICHARDSON Andrew

181 RIGLEY Peter

182 ROBERTS Ricky

183 ROBINSON Brian

184 ROSALES Dennis

185 SABINE Tom

186 SARNADSKY Kenneth

187 SATUROS Perlito

188 SCHULTZ Drew

189 SEONG Ki Young

190 SEONG Lak

191 SEWELL John

192 SHAVE Anthony

193 SKIPINA Aleksandar

194 SKIPINA Vladmir

195 SMITH Jeff

196 SMITH Ryan

197 SOLOMON Trevor

198 SONG Dong Jin

199 SONG Kichul

200 SOUN Sareun

201 STIVALETTA Joey

202 STOJOSKI Zoran

203 SUYAT Bienvenido

204 SYGUWA Richard

205 TANNER Bradley

206 TAYLOR Raeminn

207 TENISELI Leo

208 THOMAS Gary

209 THOMPSON Tui

210 THOMSON Matthew

211 TURNER Paul

212 TURNER Anthony

213 VALENTINO Anthony

214 VAN TRAN Khanh

215 VENTURA Fabio

216 VOICAN Jacob

217 VOICAN Marian

218 WALKER Trevor

219 WALLACE Joe

220 WALSH Bruce

221 WARD Ches

222 WEBB Luke

223 WESTON Steve

224 WILLIAMS Neil

225 WILSON Peter

226 WOJTCZAK Natasha

227 YARRAN Ray

228 YATES Darrell

229 YEE Ah Meng (Sunny)

230 YOUNG Jamie

231 YOUNG Suk Park (Yong?)

232 ZABEL Ernest

Freo Group Limited

233 BRAND Gregory

234 BROWN Keith

235 CASEY Michael

236 CHAPPEL Harold

237 CLINCH Fred

238 COUTTS Andrew

239 DEVINE Robert

240 FARIU Terry

241 FULLERTON Paul

242 GANTER Jake

243 GATHERCOLE SMITH Carl

244 HENRY Anthony

245 HOPPER Catherine

246 JOHNS Steven

247 KEDDELL, Mason

248 LUBRIG Alfred

249 MATHISON Warwick

250 MILES Blake

251 MITCHELL Euan

252 MORGAN Sherman

253 NGATAMARIKI Tangi

254 NOYES Paul

255 PASSMORE Brett

256 PAYNE Graham

257 PUERTA David

258 SARDELIC Antony

259 SIMS Luke

260 SMITH Malcolm

261 STEVENSON, Carl

262 STEPHENSON, Keith

263 STUBING Bradley

264 UPOKO Tuaere

265 VAUGHAN Michelle

Modern Access Services

266 ANDERSON Joshua

267 AUGUST Anthony

268 BARBER Russell

269 Biddiscombe John

270 Blythin Kevin

271 Brinkley Kristian

272 Brooksby John

273 Burkhardt Ron

274 Capolicchio Brett

275 Cavallaro Domenico

276 Cooper Stephen

277 Cooper Tasman

278 Cornish Mark

279 Daly Jarrod

280 Dodd Adrian

281 Evans Simon

282 Finn Beryl

283 Freeman Steven

284 Glentworth Brooke

285 Godrei Pradeep

286 Goodson Matthew

287 Green Kori

288 Hartley Mark

289 Hayes Karim

291 Hooton Nathan

292 Howard Ben

293 Hugill Christopher

294 Juras Frank

295 Kino Aaron

296 Lee Damien

297 Mam Nara

298 Mam Narak

299 Marshall Shane

301 Mcnamara David

302 Mcnulty Marin

303 Minifie Terry

304 Morrison Jon

305 Murray Mike

306 Namok Mark

307 Nunes Andrew

308 Osborn Christopher

309 Parker Troy

310 Peacock Michael

311 Peterson Trevor

312 Phillips Richard

313 Phillips-Mitchell Gavin

314 Pitt Stanley

315 Ratima Khimbo

316 Reuben Marvin

317 Revill Brent

318 Roberts James

319 Sant Troy

320 Sarson Jason

321 Smith Steve

322 Smith Shayne

323 Suter Julian

324 Thompson Brian

325 Tito David

326 Van Rooyen Kristy

327 Warahi Damian

328 Wells Brayden

329 Williams Adam

330 Willing Mark

331 Wrathall Shannon

332 Yates Scott

333 Yu Lida

Mammoet Australia Pty Ltd

334 AINSWORTH Shaun

335 AUSTIN Grant

336 AXTON Shannen

337 BALL David

338 BATZLOFF Mark

339 BELLESINI Katie

340 BICKLER Adrian

341 BOLTON Lyall

342 CLIFFORD Tully

343 COHEN Andrew

344 COLEMAN Ronald

345 CRAVEN Matthew

346 DICKINSON Pauline

347 DIXON Shayne

348 DUNNE Maria

349 DRUMMOND Matthew

350 EDDINGTON Spencer

351 EMMOTT Rebecca

352 FITZGERALD Warren

353 FLETT Steve

354 FURLONG Katrina

355 GRAY Matthew

356 GRAY Richard

357 GREENWAY Darryl

358 HARDWICK James

359 HARRISON Brian

360 HINES Gregory

361 HOPKINS Gareth

362 HOW Adrian

363 LAMBERT Harold

364 LANDGREN Mick

365 LYE Warwick

366 McDONALD Ronald

367 McVINISH, Rosalee

368 MITCHELL Liam

369 NELSON Steven

370 OREILLY Richard

371 OTT Jonathan

372 REED Michael

373 RETTKE Robert

374 RICHARDSON Matthew

375 ROFF Andrew

376 ROGERS Malcolm

377 ROSS Adam

378 ROWE Greig

379 ROWE Raymond

380 SCHWARZ Peter

381 SEYMOUR Ashley

382 TAYLOR Nathan

383 TAYLOR John

384 THOMSON Gary

385 WALKER Ken

386 WAUGH Duncan

387 WELLS Brian

388 ZELINSKI Sonya

Monadelphous Engineering
Associates Pty Ltd

389 ABBOTT Ben

390 ALCIBAR Philip

391 ALEXANDER Raymond

392 ALI Paul

393 ALLSOP Simon

394 ANDERSON Steven

395 ANDERSON Stephen

396 ARMSTRONG Paul

397 ATKINS Daniel

398 ATKINSON Khan

399 BACHE Guy

400 BAKER Chris

401 Balazic Robert

402 BALLINGER Paul

403 BAMBERRY Russell

404 BARRON Dale

405 BARRY Peter

406 BATE Gordon

407 BELL Robert

408 BERRIDGE Helen

409 BOXALL Darren

410 BOZTEPE Serkan

411 BRODIE Peter

412 BRUEN Gerard (Ged)

413 BURCH Michelle

414 BURGETT James

415 BURTON Daniel

417 BUTLER John

418 BUTTACAVOLI Anthony

419 CABRILOVSKI George

420 CALBALA Deborah

421 CALCOTT David

422 CALLANAN Barry

423 CANAL Jose

424 CARRIES Louis

425 CARRUTHERS John

426 CARTER Chad

427 CARY Eric

428 CERVINI Marc

429 CHAPMAN Scott

430 CLAPHAM Wade

431 CLARKE Tony

432 CLAY Adam

433 COLEMAN Matthew

434 COLLARD Kelvin

435 COLLINS Wayne

436 COLLINS David

437 COOK Ben

438 COULTER Jesse

439 CRAWFORD Robert (Dave)

441 CROSS Sidney

442 CUMMING Kenneth

444 CURTIS Robert

445 DACOMBE John

446 DASTOL Ronald

447 DAVIES Jason

448 DAVIS Greg

449 DAW Robert

450 DAW Stephen

451 DAWES Shane

452 DAY Matthew

453 DEMAIO Sam

454 DERRICK Robert

455 DEVINE Scott

456 DOWLING Graham

457 DOWSETT Keith

458 DRACA Bogoljub (Bob)

459 DUNCAN Anthony

460 DUNN Deborah

461 DWYER Regan

462 ECCLES Lee

463 ELDERIDGE Ben

464 ELLIOTT Francis

465 ELPEZ Marijan

466 EMMANUEL Harry

467 EMMERSON Russell

468 EMSLIE John

469 ERCEG James

470 EVANS Zach

471 FARRUGIA Dennis

472 FERGUSON Margaret

473 FERGUSON Michael

474 FIELD Michael

475 FITZROY Corey

476 FLAHAVIN Joseph

477 FLETCHER Ryan

478 FORBES Adrian

479 FORREST Robert

480 FOWLES Tony

481 FRADL Robert

482 GARTON Steven

483 GILLESPIE Don

484 GIVNEY Shane

485 GLASS Tyson

486 GLASS Victor

487 GLYNN Martin

488 GODFREY Andrew

489 GOLUB Aleksander

490 GOODALL Adrian

491 GRILLS Dean

492 GRIVINS Justin

493 HAINES Danny

494 HARRIS Robert

495 HARRIS Patricia

496 HAYES Clint

497 HEBBARD Leith

498 HEBDEN Garth

499 HIKU Frank

500 HODDY Graeme

501 HOLLOWAY Rodney

502 HOLT Robert

503 HOOYBERG Eric

504 HOPPE Dennis

505 HOWARD Morgan

506 HUGHES Murray

507 HULL Kevin

508 ISAIA Ben

509 JANNEKER Clinton

510 JARRETT Grant

511 JONES Peter

512 JONES Rodney

513 JONES Richard

514 JONES Raymond

516 KAAKA Rima

517 KATSCHNER Lothar

518 KEEGAN Daniel

519 KEILY Shaun

520 KELLY Gavin

521 KELLY Shane

522 KELLY Mick

523 Kemp Michael

524 KING Joel

525 KING Mark

526 KORVER Glenn

527 KOUKA Boydie

528 KRAKOUER James

529 LAING Derek

530 LAMB Darren

531 LARSEN Leonard

532 LAWRENCE John

533 LAWRIE Lachlan

534 LEANING Jason

535 LEO Graham

536 LEONARD Troy

537 LEWIS Nerralie

538 LI Andrew

539 LIEBKE Steven

540 LIVINGSTON Anthony

541 LLOYD Martin

542 LORD Michael

543 LORTAN Gregory (Greg)

544 LOTZ Terrence

545 LOWE Darren

546 LUELING Freddi

547 LYONS Brock

548 MANN James

549 MATTHEWS Terry

550 MCCLUTCHIE Eugene

551 MCDONALD Malcolm

552 MCDONALD Cathy (Cate)

553 MCFARLANE Craig

554 MCGUIRE Alastair

555 MCLAREN Anne

556 MCLAREN Mark

557 MCMILLAN Brett

558 MELLOR Trevor

559 MILNE Andrew

560 MINNER Robert

561 MLEZIVA Sacha

562 MOONEY Matthew

563 MORRIS Patrick

564 MORTIMER Andrew

565 MURPHY Phillip

566 NAIDOO Manivasagan

567 NANKIVELL Mark

568 NELIS Joseph

569 NGAWHIKA Shane

570 NICHOLLS Andrew

571 NOCK Alan

572 NOVOSELL Erwin

573 O'MALLEY David

574 ORMEROD Jacqueline

575 OTTAWAY Kate

576 PAJONK Michael

577 PALEVNO Dennis

578 PATU Tuakaua

579 PATYI Richard

580 PAVLIK Robert

581 PAYNE Mark

582 PEDLER Robert

583 PETERSEN Malcolm

584 POOLE Michael

585 PRIDDETH Jake

586 PUATA Troy

587 PUATA Aaron

588 PURCEL Michael

589 QUALTROUGH Scott

590 QUINLESS Fred

592 RANN Dylan

593 RAYMAN Carl

594 REGAN Les

595 REID Jethro

596 RIDDELL Jeffrey

597 RITCHIE Jason

598 RIVAS Anthony

599 ROBERTS Douglas

600 ROBERTSON James (Jim)

601 ROSANES Renie

602 ROSS Yancy-lee

603 RUDOLF Renee

604 SANDERS Michael

605 SAXBY Zallman

606 SCALES Simon

607 SCANTLEBURY Robin

608 SCHAECHE Eric

609 SCHOONER Raimona (Joe)

610 SCULLION Joseph

611 SCULLION Neil

612 SEMMENS Jai

613 SHAND Derick

614 SHELLY Ben

615 SIMPSON Tahi

616 SLOMAN Janet

617 SMITH Barry

618 SMITH Peter

619 SMITH Bruce

620 SPARKE Cassie

621 SPRAGUE Matthew

622 STARCEVIC Martin

623 STRANG Matthew

624 SWINDLEHURST Kevin

625 TAHI TAHI Antonio

626 TAMATEA Patrick

627 TANGIORA Clinton

628 TANNER Buwyn

629 TASKER Patricia

630 TE MIHA Deon

631 THEXTON Gary

632 TICEHURST Michael

633 TIMMERMANS James

634 TOAKLEY Matthew

635 TOMS Robin

636 TYSON Shane

637 VAAI Lasalosi

638 VAN EETEN Daniel

639 VARIAN Shane

640 VELLA Jesse

641 VOZAREVIC Bruno

642 WATSON Rebecka

643 WEARNE Adam

644 WEBB Paul

645 WEIR Kristian

646 WETERE Louis

647 WHELPDALE Eddie

648 WHITE Ramon

649 WHITE Brett

650 WILKINSON Norman

651 WILLIAMS Keetha

652 WILLSHIRE Andrew (Andy)

653 WILSON Troy

654 WINTLE Steven

655 WOODLAND Jamie

656 WOOLLASTON Simon

657 WRIGHT Colin

658 YEONG Kam

RCR Positron Pty Ltd

659 Abelha D. E.

660 Biskup M. E.

661 Davey S. E.

662 Eggers S. TA.

663 Everitt J. E.

664 Gardener R. LE

665 Gouge J. LE.

666 Guyatt D. LE.

667 Harrison R. E.

668 Heard D. E.

669 Heywood S. LE.

670 Holmes P. E.

671 Howard T

672 Jordan A. TA.

673 Kennedy W. BM

674 Kimpton T. E.

675 Kirkpatrick K.TF

676 Leach A. TA.

677 Lette B. E.

678 Mccartney N. TA

679 Meardi A. TA.

680 Message S. TA

681 Mitchell L. E.

682 Mulvey P. E.

683 Perak A. TA.

684 Phillips D. E.

685 Priestly M. TA.

686 Sheasby R. TA.

687 Smith B. E.

688 Spangen S. E.

689 Watts S. E.

690 Webb B. E.

691 Wilks B. E.

PCH Group Ltd

692 ASIATA Moses

693 ATKINS Te

694 BISHOP Matthew

695 BLAKE Sean

696 BRYAN Jason

697 BURNS Darryl

698 COLLINS Craig

699 COOMBES Michael

700 COOPER Layton

701 COOPER Aaron

702 DAVID Julian

703 DEVINE Cash

704 DIOSAN Radu

705 DROLLET Kayne

706 DUNN Nigel

707 EMERY Manny

708 FIAMANYA Dzifa

709 FINCARYK Oscar

710 FORBES Anthony

711 GABRIEL Iarere (Eddie)

712 GARNER Stephen

713 GATHERCOLE-SMITH Justin

714 GIBBS Jacob

715 GLASS Steven

716 HAPE Kahu

717 HARTLEY Dean

718 HAYES Craig

719 HINAKI Randal

720 HOWE Duane

721 IEREMIA Sipili

722 IND Matthew

723 JAYME Steven

724 JENSEN Ross

725 KAISER Michael

726 KEARNS Clinton

727 KELLY Stuart

728 KIRTLEY Jai

729 KLAPKO Andrew

730 KOMENE Robert

731 KOUKA Bennett

732 LANDMETER Harry

733 LODGE Dewayne

734 LULHAM Marc

735 MAEA John

736 MANU Harley

737 MANU Jeremia

738 MANU John

739 MANUEL Jardine

740 MASON Terence

741 MATENGA Huki

742 MCCRORY Bernard

743 McCRORY Jason

744 MEDLAND Dean

745 MILLS Stephen

746 MORRIS Joseph

747 MURPHY Wayne

748 NGAMOKI Pita

749 ORLOWSKI David

750 PAYNE Drew

751 PEMBERTON Paul

752 PIRIHI Jade

753 POTTER Leonard

754 RAHARUHI Kiha

755 RAINE Chris

756 REARDON Daniel

757 ROBINSON Michael

758 ROWSELL Jason

759 SHELFORD Angus

760 SMITH James

761 STONE Glenn

762 TEMAARI Ryan

763 TEPOHE Nathan

764 TEPU Patrick

765 THOMAS Jamie

766 THOMPSON Stacy

767 THURSTON Troy

768 TOGIA Sasa

769 TUPAEA Matthew

770 WALKER Stephen

771 WATENE Cory

772 WILLIAMSON Stephen

773 WIPERI Jason

774 DIEHL Armin

775 KELLY James

John Holland Pty Ltd - Savcor Finn (subcontractors)

776 BROWNING Paul

777 DAWSON Samual

778 HOWELL Justin

RCR Construction & Maintenance Pty Ltd

779 CAMPBELL Danny

780 DODSLEY Andrew

781 ELBOROUGH Kimley

782 FIELD Christopher

783 FRASER Laureen

784 FRASER Trevor

785 HAWKINS Stephen

786 LAMB Gregory

787 PARVIN Stephen

788 PLUNKETT Kevin

789 PORTER Mark

790 SEABURN Kevin

791 SOMERVILLE Ryan

792 SUTHERLAND Travis

793 TOKI Mitch

794 WALKER Wayne

795 WEBB Adrian

Downer EDI Engineering Power Pty Ltd

796 ANDERSON David

797 AYRES Brett

798 BEETS Bryan

799 BENJAMIN Edmund

800 BENSON Scott

801 BOSCO Adrian

802 BOWER Peter

803 BUSINOSKI Ilija

804 CAMPBELL Rhys

805 CARR Bryne

806 CHEAL John

807 CHRISTENSEN, Ross

808 COBB Brett

809 COOPER Dwanie

810 DOCKERTY Michael

811 DOHERTY Paul

812 ESDALE Adam

813 GIBBS Ian

814 GOODALL Darren

815 GORDON-DAVISON Kayne

816 GRECI David

817 HANNAFORD Gareth

818 HARRIS Guy

819 HARVEY Brian

820 HOWE Ben

821 KENNING Darrell

822 LEACH Gareth

823 MACALE David

824 MARCINKOWSKI Laurie

825 OLDHAM Scott

826 PEGRUM Brad

827 POON Ryan

828 PRIMROSE Darren

829 ROACH Greg

830 ROBERTS Jenny

831 ROBERTS Mick

832 SANDERS Jason

833 SELLECK Syd

834 SHEATHER Luke

835 SMITH Nathan

836 SODEN Derek

837 STEPHENSON Tony

838 STONER Andrew

839 SULLIVAN Scott

840 SWAN David

841 TAYLOR John

842 THOMAS Jamie

843 TURNER Robert

844 TWYFORD James

845 VAN ROOYEN Kelly

846 VAN WANROOY Justin

847 WALTERS Steve

848 WILSON Jeff

849 ABBOTT, Bill

850 BLIOKAS, Rob

851 CAKE, Mathew

852 CORBETT, Adam

853 KERR, Brian

854 KOVACESKI, Angel

855 MARAS, John

856 WELSH, Gary

857 WILSON, Michael

858 MARSH, Tony

CBI Constructors Pty Ltd

859 ADAMS Brendan

860 ALLMAN Robert

861 ARCARO Murray

862 ARCARO Nicholas

863 ATKINSON Stephen

864 BACON Kenneth

865 BAEZ Juan

866 BAEZ Sergio

867 BAIL Jason

868 BAILEY Troy

871 BECKER Peter

872 BECKMAN Alan

873 BELL Murray

874 BEVAN Alan

875 BOBOS Carl

876 BRENNAN Stephen

877 BRITTAIN Timothy

878 BROOKS Raymond

879 BUTTARS Anton

880 CAMERON Alistair

881 CARMICHAEL James

882 CASTRO Dean

883 CHRISTENSEN Kenneth

884 CLARK Harley

885 CLARK Robert

886 CLEARY James

887 COELHO John

888 CONNELL Travis

889 CROSIER Andrew

890 CYPHER Justin

891 DODD Peter

892 DONDAS Michael

893 DONNELLY Brett

894 DUPLESSIS Johannes

895 EDWARDS David

896 ELPHICK Jeffrey

897 FAUSTINO Victor

898 FERREIRA Jose

899 FRONTE Salvatore

900 GARDINER Jason

901 GARNIER-BRADLEY Jason

902 GOGOLL Joel

903 GOODALL Tay

904 GROTH William

905 HAKIWAI Stirling

906 HARDINGHAM Adrian

907 HARRIS Ike

908 HEGARTY Steven

909 HOUSE Clayton

910 HUMPHREY David

911 HUNWICK Phillip

912 JARRETT Glenn

913 JOHNS Robert

914 JOHNSTON Anthony

915 KELLY Matthew

916 KINGHORN William

917 KOVACESKA Menka

918 KOVACESKI Donco

919 KRALJEVIC-KRUBIC Josip

920 KRUGER Rodney

921 LANE Darrin

922 LANNIN Bradley

923 LAROSA Agostino

924 LE CERF Garry

925 LEE Mu Yeun

926 LILLEY Joseph

927 LIM Nao

928 LUDLAM John

929 MABBOTT Bruce

930 MacKINNON Graeme

931 MANNERING Peter

932 MARLOW Michael

933 MARTIN James

934 MARTIN Trevor

935 MATEIU Gherge

936 MAXWELL Daniel

937 McCABE Mark

938 McINERNEY John

939 MCINERNEY Todd

940 MCKENNA Henry

941 MCKENZIE Alan

942 MCKINNON David

943 MILLER Bradley

944 MILROY Gary

945 MINNS Neil

946 MITCHELL Robert

947 MORLEY Robert

948 NEWSHAM Garry

949 NOBLE Brendan

950 O'SHEA Daniel

951 PAYNE Kenneth

952 PERRY Marcus

953 PESTANA Jose

954 PIRIHI Dylan

955 RAZI-PANAH Jarwad

956 RICE Mark

957 RYAN John

958 SANDERS Dean

959 SANSOM Gregory

960 SCHMITT Gregory

961 SCOTT Robert

962 SHIELD Keith

963 SMYTHE Jason

964 SNELLIN Ronald

965 STUURSTRAAT Shannan

966 SURRIDGE Daniel

967 SVILICICH Lee

968 SWINNEY Antony

969 TAMAPUA Allan

970 TAYLOR Kim

971 TUKUAFU Finau

972 VLUG Bruce

973 WAIARIKI Paul

974 WALSH John

975 WARNER Paul

976 WATTS Priscilla

977 WEAVER Blake

978 WEAVER Mark

979 WEIR Mitchell

980 WETERE Tirau

981 WOLSKI Daniel

982 WOOD Leon

983 WOODWARD Sam

United Group Resources Pty Ltd

985 Lional Abrahams

986 Lesley Ajaran

988 Nathan Arbery

989 Cody Arvidson

990 Mark Ashcroft

991 Adrian Baillie

992 Jonathan Barclay

993 Kenneth Barclay

994 Stephen Barnett

995 Rolando Bazaez

996 Louis Beaunoir

997 Jason Behncke

998 Jan Bennett

999 Troy Benton

1000 Arjun Bhoi

1001 Nitin Bhosale

1002 Marcel Biggar

1003 Francis Blampied

1004 Tommy Bonke

1005 Benjamin Boocock

1006 Nathan Bosworth

1007 Milorad Brakus

1008 Christian Brekalo

1009 Nick Brekalo

1010 Andrew Brennan

1011 Christopher Browne

1012 Gabriel Bruno

1013 Marcus Burke

1014 Craig Cameron

1015 Malcolm Carr

1016 Dean Cassidy

1017 Hasan Ceric

1018 Tony Chipchase

1019 Juho Choi

1020 Clint Chrisp

1022 Gavin Coleman

1023 Jye Coleman

1024 Dean Collins

1025 Andrew Collinson

1026 Collis James

1028 John Couts

1029 Mark Coverly

1030 Joshua Cruice

1031 Alfredo Da Silva

1033 Trevor Datson

1035 Brian Davies

1036 Jeffrey Davis

1037 Brett Dawes

1038 Gerrit De Blanken

1039 James DeBruin

1040 Beau Deverall

1041 Claude Devos

1042 Manuel Dias

1043 Radwan Eltchelebi

1044 Joao Felizardo

1045 David Fergusson

1047 Terence Fisher

1048 Mark Fleay

1049 Craig Fleming

1050 Katie Forbes

1051 Terrence Fox

1052 Jason Francis

1053 Michael Franke

1054 Damien Freeth

1055 John Frino

1056 Steven Gaby

1057 Tim Gamble

1058 David Gera

1060 Paul Gnech

1061 Shaun Goldstone

1062 Anthony Gostlow

1064 Phillip Grevell

1065 Roger Griffiths

1066 Michael Hagan

1067 Adrian Hage

1069 Peter Harris

1071 Anthony Hayes

1072 John Heckscher

1073 Geoffrey Height

1074 Todd Heron

1075 Marcelene Heslop

1076 Graeme Hocking

1077 Peter Hoek

1078 Andrew Holden

1080 Sean Hoskins

1081 Steven Hossack

1082 Harold Houghton

1083 Mervyn Houghton

1084 Brendan Howard

1086 David Hull

1087 Joshua Humphries

1088 Glenn Hutton

1090 Elias Israel

1091 Mark Jackson

1092 Sergio Jacobs

1093 Paul Jean-Pierre

1094 Craig Jeffs

1095 John Jenkins

1096 Kenneth Johnstone

1097 Mark Jones

1098 Ray Jones

1099 Robert Jones

1100 Fabian Joule

1101 Edan Kennedy

1102 Stuart (Alvin) Kerrigan

1103 Nigel Kiedo

1104 David Knyvett

1105 Travis Ladhams

1106 Mathew Lamb

1107 Peter Law

1108 Paul Leach

1109 Chong-Won Lee

1110 Kenneth Lewins

1111 Mark Lindsay

1113 Shannon Livingstone

1114 Jason Lockhart

1115 Stephen Lowther

1116 William Lyall

1117 Donald MacKay

1118 Brett Mackie

1119 Gerarado Magtalas

1120 Simeon Magtalas

1121 Thomas Mahar

1122 Matthew Manning

1124 Garry Mansfield

1125 Felix Marriott

1126 Calvin Martin

1127 Andrew Mazlin

1128 Adam McAnany

1129 Darren McCamish

1130 Gary McCarthy

1131 Shane McClure

1132 Ian McCracken

1133 Matthew McGurgan

1134 Wayne McMahon

1136 Spencer Meade

1137 Alan Middleton

1138 Simon Mieschbuehler

1139 Kane Mita

1140 Charles Mitchell

1142 Erwin Montiere

1143 Nicholas Morley

1144 Steven Mott

1145 Steven Moxon

1146 Len Mudri

1147 Ian Mullan

1149 Christopher Murray

1150 Michael Narbey

1151 Rodney Nelson

1152 Stuart Noakes

1153 Gregory Norris

1154 Stephen Novak

1155 Thomas O'Brien

1156 Luke O'Fee

1157 Damien O'Kane

1158 Russel Olsen

1159 Martin Osborne

1160 Robert Osbourne

1161 Pavo Parad

1162 Trevor Park

1164 Graeme Penglase

1165 Mark Pertile

1166 Robert Peters

1167 Sotha Pheng

1168 Aaron Phyland

1169 David Pidgeon

1170 Robert Pippia

1171 Murray Porter

1173 Matthew Ramage

1174 Daniel Reddie

1175 Ronald Robinson

1176 Wayne Roelandts

1177 Neville Roskruge

1178 Phillip Rowell

1179 Steven Sakic

1180 Jin (Fred) Sang-Yoo

1181 Ivan Sapina

1182 Michael Schoeman

1183 Dimitru Serban

1184 Yong Shao

1185 Denny Singleton

1187 Charles Snyman

1188 Kevin Squibb

1189 Ralph Stapelfeldt

1190 Gary Stramare

1191 Clive Sucks

1192 Steven Sulenta

1193 Steven Tarran

1194 Gary Taylor

1195 Joseph Taylor

1196 Allan Thompson

1197 Bradley Thompson

1198 Christopher Thornhill

1199 Neil Tollison

1200 Alberto Tome

1201 Brett Tooby

1202 Andre Turner

1203 Mark Tutton

1204 Brendan Tye

1205 Colin Tyrer

1206 Peter Ugle

1207 Johnny Van Wyk

1208 Arnoldus Van Wyke

1209 Adrian Vandersluis

1210 Darryl Vickers

1211 Joel Von Nida

1212 Noel Webster

1213 Dean Weiss

1214 Ihaia White

1215 Drew Wickenden

1218 Gabriel Williams

1219 Gregory Williams

1220 Henry Wynkwaardt

1221 Noel Zanetti

1222 Matthew Zonta

1223 Pero Zuvela

1224 Michael Abelha

1225 Richard Alcott

1226 David Ali

1227 Noel Amari

1228 Alan Arceo

1229 Ryan Augustus

1230 Mark Bailey

1231 David Baines

1232 Fred Baker

1233 Reyon Band

1234 Antony Barlow

1235 Liam Barron

1236 Todd Bartlett

1237 Laurence Bascombe

1238 John Basso

1239 Mark Bateman

1240 Richard Bauer

1241 John Bernard

1242 Craig Berry

1244 Morgan Blake

1245 Ellen Bolton

1246 Slobodan Brakus

1247 Benjamin Brand

1248 Gavin Bratby

1249 Tyrone Briffa

1250 Darren Brown

1251 Ivaso Buac

1252 Ben Burns

1253 Ian Byrne

1254 Iain Calder

1255 Aaron Calley

1256 Ross Cameron

1257 Les Camilleri

1259 Luke Cashman

1260 Damien Chant

1261 Michael Christensen

1263 Paul Cole

1265 Anthony Cooper

1266 Jason Cornwell

1267 Clyde Cowley

1268 Bianca Coyne

1269 Michael Crook

1271 Kathleen Cunningham

1272 Graeme Daniel

1273 Mathias Dann

1274 Andrew Darcy

1275 Andrew Davies

1276 Kevin Davis

1277 Gary Davison

1278 Joe De Faria

1279 Matthew De Glanville

1280 Chad De Rooy

1281 Mark Delaney

1282 Wade Den Ridder

1283 Matthew Denton

1284 Daniele Dimasi

1285 Arnolda Do Carmo

1286 Andrew Dobson

1287 Tony Dobson

1289 Roland Edwards

1290 Stephen Elliott

1291 Cameron Ewart

1292 Bud Feenstra

1293 Miroslav Ferluga

1294 Paulo Fernandes

1297 Tristan Fuller

1298 Andrew Gaffney

1299 Graeme Geddes

1300 Peter Geisner

1301 Nicholas George

1302 Guiseppe Giglia

1303 Chris Gillen

1304 Jose Gomes

1305 Craig Goold

1307 Ian Grace

1308 Joseph Green

1309 Phillip Green

1310 Andrew Greene

1311 Paul Grgurovic

1312 Mark Haak

1313 David Hacking

1314 Gabriel Halkyard

1315 Steven Hall

1316 Lyncon Halligan

1317 Cy Hamilton

1318 Chris Hancock

1319 Jarrid Harrison

1320 Greg Hatchett

1321 Jarrad Hawkins

1323 Luke Heaney

1324 Martin Heath

1325 Malcolm Herring

1326 Julie Hicks

1327 Nathan Hicks

1328 Ben Hodkinson

1329 Tim Holdsworth

1330 Craig Holst

1332 Karatehana Horo

1333 Kevin Howat

1334 Vince Howes

1335 Tyrone Hoys

1336 Gavin Hughes

1337 Victor Hugo

1338 Paul Hulbert

1339 Mark Huyshe

1340 Jamie Ingie

1341 Norman Jamieson

1342 Kim Jenkins

1343 Quentin Jensen

1344 Michelle Jeremiah

1345 Ashley Jones

1346 Bodhi Jones

1347 Martin Jones

1348 Steve (Slobodan) Jovevski

1349 Savo Katic

1350 Kosta Katsidis

1351 James Keene

1352 Paul Kelly

1353 David Kemp

1354 Joshua Klynsoon

1355 Milan Krstanoski

1356 Tonganu Kukutai

1357 Nathan Lake

1358 Daniel Lawrence

1359 Jeffrey Lawson

1360 Shane Leworthy

1361 Robin Lilly

1362 Charles Liness

1363 William Logan

1364 Christopher Luta

1365 Jason MacDonald

1366 Ivan Macukat

1367 Callum Malloch-Smith

1368 Victor Margarido

1369 Cleopas Mashuta

1370 Craig Maxwell

1372 Dean McBride

1373 Craig McCartney

1374 Charles McClellan

1375 Duncan McDonald

1376 Ian McDonald

1377 Nicole McGinty

1378 Allan McKinnon

1379 Ross McMiles

1380 Alan McMillan

1381 William McShane

1382 Kenneth Mendoza

1383 Steven Mijailovic

1384 Charles Miller

1385 Phillip Millington

1386 Benjamin Morcom

1387 Matthew Morehu

1390 Jeremi Musulin

1391 Glen Neal

1392 Brent Neill

1393 Tim Nelson

1394 Justin Noakes

1395 Nowak Woyciech

1396 Aurelio Nunes

1397 Ashley O'Brien

1398 Tim Ogden

1399 Mao Ouk

1400 David Ovens

1403 Graham Pearce

1404 Ben Penglase

1405 Joel Penglase

1406 Ashley Pickles

1407 Darryl Pickles

1408 Ryan Pickles

1409 John Pratt

1410 John Preston

1411 Colin Price

1412 Curtis Ransfield

1413 Gerald Ransfield

1414 Steven Reid

1415 Glen Robinson

1416 Paul Roche

1417 Kerry Rossiter-McClaren

1418 Rodrigo Ruiz

1419 Joseph Ryder

1420 Grgo Saric

1421 Moreno Serramono

1422 Jose Simoes

1423 Kenneth Simon

1424 Todd Sitnikoski

1425 Shelby Skinner

1426 Hamish Smith

1427 Mark Smith

1428 Paul St John

1429 Kurt Stellenburg

1430 Andrew Stevens

1431 Kathy Stiberc

1432 Selina Stolp

1434 Wayne Sutherland

1435 James Taylor

1436 Jeremy Teaia

1437 Shane Thomas

1438 Leslie Thompson

1439 Paul Todd

1440 Karl Travers

1441 Joshua Trunfio

1442 Herbert Tucker

1443 Angela Tumney

1444 Keith Turnbull

1445 Matthew Uepa

1446 Raul Uriona

1447 Ugur Uysaler

1448 Andrea Vaega

1449 Christopher Van Arkel

1450 Liam Wakefield

1451 Michael Walker

1453 Alan Walker

1454 Simon Wallace

1455 Steve Waltl

1456 Michael Webb

1457 Paul Webb

1458 Filomena Weston

1460 Rodney Williams

1461 Jason Wilson

1462 Daryl Wood

1463 John Wyllie

1464 Tyron Youlden

1465 Leslie Young

1466 Matthew Young

1467 Roman Zasun

1468 James Zauch

1469 Charles Bell

1470 Richard D'Costa

1471 Jarrad Garrick

1472 James Odiam

1473 Colin Searle

1474 Joe Silk

1475 David Attrill

1476 Vincenzo Bonavita

1478 Corrie Bush

1479 Ben Cattalini

1480 Daniel Cattalini

1481 Daniel Christian

1482 Lance Cockayne

1485 Darren Evans

1489 Kelvin Gibbon

1494 Ahmad Intekheb

1495 Mark Jenkinson

1497 George LeFebre

1498 Edward Light

1506 Paulose Kulavelil

1507 Matthew Pearson

1509 David Sproule

1510 Colin Swasbrook

1511 Reece Tacey

1512 Alex Varga

1515 John Winter

1516 Glenn Withers

1517 Paul Young

1519 Nicholas Hurst

1520 Vicky Leefe

1521 Charles Lowe

1522 Lesley Sermon

AustLII: Copyright Policy | Disclaimers | Privacy Policy | Feedback
URL: http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/cases/cth/FCA/2010/71.html